Re:Welcome to the "neomedieval era": are states becoming obs...
by tptacek on Saturday February 10, 2024 @04:40PM
(#39330488)
So there's a colorable argument that the popular vote is not a reliable indicator of public opinion (though: as someone involved in local politics where most of the advocacy seems to involve "working the refs" by trying to convince electeds that the people support something starkly different than what they voted for, I remind you of the distinction between stated and revealed preferences).
But the popular vote here was brought up as a rebuttal to your claim that Trump's electoral success, which was a pure product of electoral gamesmanship (I mean that here in a value-neutral, descriptive way), was an indicator of a cultural shift. If the popular vote isn't an indicator of the public consciousness, the Electoral College can't be either; it is strictly less representative.
I don't think the Democratic party has ever been as unified on immigration as you're implying it is here, but that's neither here nor there.
But the popular vote here was brought up as a rebuttal to your claim that Trump's electoral success, which was a pure product of electoral gamesmanship (I mean that here in a value-neutral, descriptive way), was an indicator of a cultural shift. If the popular vote isn't an indicator of the public consciousness, the Electoral College can't be either; it is strictly less representative.
I don't think the Democratic party has ever been as unified on immigration as you're implying it is here, but that's neither here nor there.