News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by dkrich on Saturday May 05, 2012 @02:45PM (#3932871)
I don't think it's a coincidence that the major proponents of doing away with traditional higher education and questioning the value of a college degree are people with at least one degree (in many instances advanced degrees as well) from very prestigious institutions. They believe that in a practical sense, what you really need to know to perform you can gain more efficiently by doing. They ask "Who knows better than somebody with expensive degrees how worthless they are?"

I completely disagree with that and I believe the opposite is true. Only people without degrees can speak reliably about whether they regret the decision or not. They actually put themselves on the line. I'm not convinced when I hear people with degrees say that they wish they had known that they didn't need them before or that they would have been just as well without them. That's like somebody who paid for flood insurance claiming "who knows better than I how worthless flood insurance is?" Perhaps the guy down the street who didn't buy it and lost his house.

Edit: And to the author's point about iTunes vs buying full albums- that analogy is faulty. There have been community colleges around for many, many years, but the reality is that companies just don't value individual coursework as favorably as an entire degree, particularly one from a prestigious school. The purchaser of a song has very different objectives than a hirer. A song purchaser wants one song and does not want to pay ten times the price to buy an entire album which might have three songs that he likes. Clearly, single purchases are more efficient.

But when it comes to hiring, there is no added cost. If I am hiring for a position with a stated salary, I want the most qualified person I can find. If I can hire a guy with three degrees in Computer Science from MIT, I don't really care about the guy with the Microsoft and Cisco certification, even if those are things that are precisely what you need to know on the job. College is absolutely an intelligence test and screening tool, and people are naive to believe that it isn't. If you pull back and decide you are going to turn down MIT and go learn just the skills you need for your job, there are going to be 5,000 people lined up behind you ready to saddle themselves with debt and work through four years of college to get the degree and you will facing an uphill battle. So in the case of iTunes, a comparable situation is if I had $0.99 to spend on a song, and had hundreds of full albums with that song offered for my $0.99. In that case, I am not going to buy the single song.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by yummyfajitas on Saturday May 05, 2012 @04:00PM (#3933104)
College is absolutely an intelligence test and screening tool, and people are naive to believe that it isn't.

If correct, college is merely a wasteful arms race - many people wasting resources to outcompete others in a zero-sum competition for a fixed set of jobs.

Thus, we should tax colleges and education in order to discourage people from attending, as well as construct cheaper screening mechanisms and encourage their use. For example, we could scrap subsidies for education (e.g., state colleges) and replace them with standardized testing centers.

If far fewer people went to college, it would be much more costly for employers to reward wasteful signalling.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by dkrich on Saturday May 05, 2012 @05:00PM (#3933262)
> Thus, we should tax colleges and education in order to discourage people from attending, as well as construct cheaper screening mechanisms and encourage their use. For example, we could scrap subsidies for education (e.g., state colleges) and replace them with standardized testing centers.

I do not consider myself a republican or tea partier, but I really despise these types of plans aimed at controlling behavior. It works in some cases, but this is not something the government should be mucking with. They've done enough damage to higher education as it is. The last thing the US should be doing is making it even harder for kids to go to college. If anything they should be giving more money to the schools to make it affordable. The problem with college is not what you do or don't learn. Every form of school will involve wasted time. The real problem is the cost to attend.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by yummyfajitas on Saturday May 05, 2012 @05:16PM (#3933300)
I don't know what republicans and the tea party have to do with this. I'm making a simple economic argument.

Based on your reasoning, attending college has social costs and no social benefits. I.e., if you go to college and I don't, you get the job and I don't. If neither of us went to college, one of us would still get the job.

So your college attendance merely redistributes jobs from others to you, and destroys the wealth it took to educate you. This is a classic example of a market failure and a classic use case for pigouvian taxes.

While helping a few kids go to college would benefit them, the benefit would only come at the expense of others (the guy you won't hire because he lacks a pointless degree). So why do you want to do this?

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by dkrich on Saturday May 05, 2012 @07:23PM (#3933609)
Republicans and tea-partiers tend to favor less government. When people hear somebody say something that coincides with that point of view they often assume the person is a republican.

>Based on your reasoning, attending college has social costs and no social benefits. I.e., if you go to college and I don't, you get the job and I don't. If neither of us went to college, one of us would still get the job.

Not at all. I think people who have a degree appear more favorable if all other things are equal. Many jobs have a degree listed as prerequisite. If neither of us has one then neither of us will be getting the job.

There are just a whole lot of assumptions present in your argument: that a college degree is worthless and that having obtained a college degree is all that differentiates two applicants. Clearly the degree is not pointless if the best jobs are given to those who have them. There is no market failure. If the market for non-college graduates were hotter than the market for college graduates, then college would be free and most would have to close.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by yummyfajitas on Sunday May 06, 2012 @08:08AM (#3934901)
Many jobs have a degree listed as prerequisite. If neither of us has one then neither of us will be getting the job.

Many jobs have wearing a suit as a prerequisite. Would employers simply not hire anyone and close their doors if everyone refused to wear a suit?

Clearly the degree is not pointless if the best jobs are given to those who have them.

Clearly a suit is not pointless if the best jobs are given to those who have them.

You are completely missing the point. The issue is that the degree is socially harmful while being individually beneficial, according to your own arguments in favor of receiving one.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by dkrich on Sunday May 06, 2012 @10:08AM (#3935148)
> Many jobs have wearing a suit as a prerequisite. Would employers simply not hire anyone and close their doors if everyone refused to wear a suit?

That's my point. In a market that has many buyers and few sellers, the buyers do not get to set the price. So there would never be a scenario in which everyone would refuse to wear a suit. Creating hypotheticals in which every job applicant acts in tandem is a pointless endeavor. If the employer states that you have to show up at 8, wear a suit, have a degree, accept a certain rate of pay, and never leave before 6pm, you will do those things. If you don't, that's okay, somebody else will. Just like I can't set the price of the iPhone just because I don't like paying the full price. The day Apple has trouble selling iPhones then I might be able to negotiate.

> The issue is that the degree is socially harmful while being individually beneficial, according to your own arguments in favor of receiving one.

These are inferences that you are making. I do not think that formal education is harmful to society. The U.S. has the greatest higher education system in the world by a long, long, shot. I do not think it is wise for us to try to tear down from within one of our greatest competitive advantages. There is a reason that people from all over the world are fighting to get into our schools.

BTW, I find it kinda curious that you are railing so hard against higher ed. Was it before or after your third degree that you decided education is such a poor investment?

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by yummyfajitas on Sunday May 06, 2012 @11:08AM (#3935278)
Was it before or after your third degree that you decided education is such a poor investment?

I didn't claim that a degree is a poor investment for individuals, I claim that the signalling aspect of education is harmful to society. Please try to actually understand an argument before disputing it.

Incidentally, I concluded that education is primarily signalling while I was selling it. I left academia in part because I felt I was creating very little value.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by DanBC on Sunday May 06, 2012 @08:30AM (#3934949)
> Many jobs have wearing a suit as a prerequisite. Would employers simply not hire anyone and close their doors if everyone refused to wear a suit?

You assume that bosses are rational agents. Years of idiotic decisions by idiotic bosses[1] shows otherwise.

[1] see Dilbert (1989), 'The Office', 'Office Space' (1999), etc etc.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by wisty on Saturday May 05, 2012 @03:03PM (#3932919)
> College is absolutely an intelligence test and screening tool, and people are naive to believe that it isn't.

People always say this. If it were true, it could be done far cheaper.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by dkrich on Saturday May 05, 2012 @03:29PM (#3932992)
It may be true that it could be done for cheaper if the hiring teams bought into a new system. But the course is really set by the hiring team.

There was a time when you only had to study legal books on your own and pass a bar exam to become an attorney. Law schools didn't exist until the turn of the century. Nowadays you can't seriously pursue a career in law without a law degree, and to get a top job, you have to have a degree from a top law school. This is not because the fundamentals being taught at each school are different. Rather law firms know which schools are hard to get into and simply go there to hire their talent because they figure those people are the best. Hopeful attorneys see those firms and want in, so naturally, they want to get into the top law schools. Those who don't, trickle down to the less prestigious schools where the firms that can't afford to compete with the top firms recruit, and so on. This is basically what drives the obsession with higher education in the U.S. whether it is business, law, medicine, or engineering.

Now whether a career in a prestigious firm is something you should actually want is a completely different conversation, but allowing that it is something a lot of the most eligible college graduates aspire to, the system will sustain itself.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by Turing_Machine on Saturday May 05, 2012 @03:55PM (#3933083)
"can't seriously pursue a career in law without a law degree"

It depends on what you mean by a career. There are still a few states that let you sit for the bar exam without going to law school (California is one, IIRC). That actually makes a certain degree of sense, since it's widely accepted that passing the bar exam is a MUCH more difficult hurdle than completing law school.

If you just want a career as a family lawyer, that'd certainly be a low-debt option.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by WildUtah on Saturday May 05, 2012 @05:25PM (#3933325)
California requires at least four years of full time practice at internships certified and supervised by certified lawyers before allowing one to sit for the bar exam. It's hardly a lesser burden than attending law school.

There is no state where the general public can sit for the bar.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by Turing_Machine on Sunday May 06, 2012 @10:15AM (#3935162)
"It's hardly a lesser burden than attending law school."

Internships are generally paid (If I remember correctly, some of those who've gone this route are long-term legal secretaries). Law school costs money and lots of it.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by wisty on Saturday May 05, 2012 @04:09PM (#3933129)
> Law schools didn't exist until the turn of the century.

IIRC, in the UK there were all kinds of private tutors who'd prepare students for bar / medicine exams.

But most degrees are more about attainment than accreditation. A degree doesn't let you do anything, it's just a line in a resume, and possibly some skills and connections you picked up along the way.

The question is, if it's simply a glorified 3 year intelligence / work ethics test, why can't private providers create something equivalent?

The US has some messed up law about intelligence tests being racist (for good reasons at the time - IQ tests were being used to block poorly educated blacks from doing jobs which didn't require any real IQ), but all kinds of skills tests could be managed by private providers. It could also be packaged with some kind of value added analysis. HR tends to suck at analysis, so it could be made to compliment what they do.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by dkrich on Saturday May 05, 2012 @04:56PM (#3933255)
> A degree doesn't let you do anything, it's just a line in a resume, and possibly some skills and connections you picked up along the way.

This depends greatly upon what your career goals are. But if you want to be a doctor, lawyer, or even a management consultant you have to have multiple degrees. There is virtually no other way in. I know there are niche exceptions to this rule, but generally speaking, degrees are a must.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by stcredzero on Saturday May 05, 2012 @04:42PM (#3933221)
That's like somebody who paid for flood insurance claiming "who knows better than I how worthless flood insurance is?" Perhaps the guy down the street who didn't buy it and lost his house.

What about somebody who paid for flood insurance who wasn't paid enough to fix their house? I think that person would have a good basis for commentary.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by dkrich on Saturday May 05, 2012 @05:12PM (#3933296)
Certainly, and that is a very important side of the argument. My point was that people with advanced degrees who have ascended to great success are probably the people least qualified to tell others that the expensive degrees they obtained were not worth it. Peter Thiel is a very smart man but he is not capable of assessing whether or not he would have been so successful without two degrees from Stanford.

Let's be honest though, for most high-school graduates the choice isn't between attending Stanford and going for a startup. It's between taking on debt to go to college or taking a menial job (if they can find it).