But then, if you're knowingly arguing with idiots, it's typically done more for some weird sense of fun than for the purpose of actually trying to change their mind. Even an argument between supposedly smart people (even those aware of Bayes' Theorem) doesn't result in mind changes all that often. Actually changing someone else's mind about something they already have a relatively firm belief on is at least as hard as changing your own mind.
If you think you can fully separate beliefs about separate things from another, there's a whole slew of psychology research that says you're deluded.
In my experience people who make such sweeping connections between disperate concepts, fields, events, etc usually have a very shallow understanding of the things they are tying together and tend to be conspiracy theorists, seeing patterns where none exist. Scroll through any "new age" section in your local bookstore and you will find books tying together religion, quantum physics, numerology, human health, evolution, poetry, and other areas in the hope that they are building up a wall of irrefutable evidence by sheer breadth alone. In the end, by their lack of focus, they end up having no deep argument at all and are generally profoundly wrong in at least one (if not all) of the areas they use in their arguments, deflating their entire point.