News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to (seriously) read a scientific paper by wolverine876 on Friday February 09, 2024 @07:57PM (#39322379)
I'm not sure where the absolute statements came from - only research papers, etc.

> find the discussion around a thing to be sometimes more interesting than the thing itself

Here we differ. The discussions are mostly BS, mostly misinformation, ignorance, jokes, etc. It takes a lot of reading to find a few gems. What an expert writes, in their own domain, about something they've specifically studied in detail, is far more valuable IMHO, filled with beautiful things.

I don't rule out all discussion (obviously!). But think of the papers as comments in forums - or as blog posts - but instead of a misinformed hot take, the commenter did a bunch of research in the existing literature, carefully constructed an experiment, and tried out their idea themself - and furthermore, the commenter is an expert themself, like some people who post to HN.

It would still be great to learn where you find good material, of any kind.

There are no comments on this comment yet.