News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:These states are basically begging you to get a heat pump by colechristensen on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:32PM (#39320127)
Utilities cost excesses in California are largely PG&E paying for its liability for causing wildfires in places where people probably shouldn’t live anyway.

For example Silicon Valley Power which serves Santa Clara (or something like that) has rates that are literally half as much as PG&E.

In Minnesota I’m paying for Xcel Energy’s mistakes in Texas.

Re:These states are basically begging you to get a heat pump by s1artibartfast on Friday February 09, 2024 @06:13PM (#39321672)
People should be able to live wherever they want. That doesn't imply others should have to subsidize them doing so. It is really quite simple.

If someone remote wants power, they should secure power and pay for it at a market clearing rate, given the cost and risk to deliver it.

Re:These states are basically begging you to get a heat pump by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 09, 2024 @09:37PM (#39323018)
This is something else.

California has wildfires, and climate change has made them worse. Then the people who built their houses in a silly place prone to wildfires watch them burn down. This is becoming a problem as the frequency which with it happens increases, because it can bankrupt fire insurance companies (who then can't pay claims), or make fire insurance there unaffordable and then people don't buy it, their house burns down, and you have angry constituents.

The political solution to this is to put the liability on the power company whenever possible, even though it isn't really their fault. The fire is caused by dry conditions and that wood is going up the first time there is any kind of flame anywhere near it. If it wasn't PG&E it would have been a lightning strike or something else. Having the fires less often can actually make them worse.

But the power company is a deep pocket, so if there is any way to pin the fire on them, that's what everybody wants to do, so that the uninsured people in the fire zone can collect from someone and the currently insured people who are still there don't become unable to afford fire insurance.

Then the power company raises rates on everybody in their service area, including people who don't live in high fire risk areas, because the government has them acting as the fire insurance company, but now you can't cancel your "fire insurance" without turning off your electricity and it also has to be paid by people who didn't build their house in a silly place.

Re:These states are basically begging you to get a heat pump by s1artibartfast on Saturday February 10, 2024 @02:17AM (#39324272)
I pretty strongly disagree.

There is some liability on the state and voters for anti burn policy. However, there is more liability on the PG&E for failure to adequately mitigate risk, and failure to asses and frontload charges for probable payment.

If homes are uninsurable, then they shouldn't be. That should only be an issue for an insurer and home owner to work out.

If people want to live somewhere uninsurable, or with more expensive power, I have no issue whatsoever, and won't call them silly. That is their perogitive and values. I view it the same way as if someone wants to base jump, or eat a $500 steak. I fully support them doing whatever makes them happy, as long as they don't expect me to pay for it

Re:These states are basically begging you to get a heat pump by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 10, 2024 @05:55AM (#39325211)
> However, there is more liability on the PG&E for failure to adequately mitigate risk, and failure to asses and frontload charges for probable payment.

Mitigating the risk is pointless. Wildfires are a natural occurrence in California. The ignition source is irrelevant. The fire is happening, you can't stop it.

> I fully support them doing whatever makes them happy, as long as they don't expect me to pay for it

But that's exactly what they expect you to do. Their houses are in a tinder box. There is some absurdly high probability that they'll burn. And then they're going to want to play the sympathetic victim who has just lost everything in a fire and go to the government and try to get someone else (i.e. you, via PG&E) to pay for the consequences of their choices.

The traditional way of doing this is to make the insurance pay, but they didn't have insurance because the high risk was known in advance which made the insurance unaffordable. When that's not available, the lawyers have to find someone else to sue, and in this case it's the power company.

Re:These states are basically begging you to get a heat pump by s1artibartfast on Saturday February 10, 2024 @04:02PM (#39330176)
Ignition source matters, because frequency happens. Take the camp fire. If not for PG&E, 85 people would be alive, and 16 billion in damages would be averted.

>But that's exactly what they expect you to do. Their houses are in a tinder box. There is some absurdly high probability that they'll burn.

I dont know what you think is "high probability", but it doesnt really matter. The point is that it should be between them and the power company.

I think you have a pretty distorted view of reality. PGE didnt and doesn't get sued for natural wildfires, only what they cause.

Re:These states are basically begging you to get a heat pump by AnthonyMouse on Monday February 12, 2024 @09:55PM (#39353754)
> Ignition source matters, because frequency happens.

But more frequent, smaller fires are actually better. Otherwise dead wood accumulates and then the next fire spreads faster and is harder to contain.

> Take the camp fire. If not for PG&E, 85 people would be alive, and 16 billion in damages would be averted.

And then an even worse fire would have happened later.

> The point is that it should be between them and the power company.

But the power company isn't raising rates for customers in high fire risk areas, they're raising rates for everyone. Otherwise the people in high risk areas would all cancel their electrical service because they couldn't afford it, but the power company would still have to maintain lines there because it's in their service area.

> PGE didnt and doesn't get sued for natural wildfires, only what they cause.

They're all natural wildfires. They're caused by dead wood and dry conditions.

Re:These states are basically begging you to get a heat pump by coryrc on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @04:12AM (#39368034)
Also you're forbidden from turning off your electricity in urban and suburban areas.
Re:These states are basically begging you to get a heat pump by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @04:19AM (#39368068)
> The political solution to this is to put the liability on the power company whenever possible, even though it isn't really their fault.

PG&E's liability for wildfire-related damages, blowing up San Bruno, etc., is not a political decision of where to place blame for climate-change effects, it is regular civil liability (and in some cases criminal) for damage provably attributable to acts or culpable omissions by the firm.

Re:These states are basically begging you to get a heat pump by kccqzy on Friday February 09, 2024 @07:06PM (#39322057)
It's not just about causing wildfires in places where people shouldn't live, but causing wildfires in places that no people actually live, but these places happen to be between other places where people live.