News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by quatrefoil on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @07:38PM (#39296308)
Having briefly interacted with the founders of Google a couple of times, I'm pretty sure it's by design. I think that at some point, they recognized that Google must turn into a big, boring company that communicates in platitudes. There is no other way to do it when you have 150,000 employees, trillions of dollars at stake, and every regulatory agency in the world wants a piece of you. Even in the late 2000s, when Google was one tenth the size and was near-universally loved, the model of having frank fireside conversations with execs was already stretched thin.

They basically decided they want to reap the benefits of the company's success, but work on pet projects and not be the face of this anymore. Sundar was and is a perfect pick for a CEO - that is, if you accept that Google really couldn't outrun fate.

Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by curt15 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @07:45PM (#39296378)
Does it actually take 150k employees to produce Google's output? They grew by like 30k employees since 2021 but I'm not seeing correspondingly more or better products.
Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by quatrefoil on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @08:12PM (#39296601)
I don't think it scales linearly anywhere. A significant part of the workforce is just there to provide services to the workforce itself. You have full-time engineers just maintaining tools for performance management, or for booking conference rooms, or requesting new laptops, you have legal teams for basically every country you operate in, etc. And then once these bureaucracies grow large enough, you hire people whose job is just to help others navigate the internal processes...

I mean, LinkedIn has what, 20,000 employees? If you had spherical developers in a vacuum, I doubt you'd need more than 40-50 to maintain their products, but there's more to running a tech company.

Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by michaelt on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @08:29PM (#39296722)
> A significant part of the workforce is just there to provide services to the workforce itself.

The bureaucracy is expanding to meet the needs of the expanding bureaucracy.

Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by dzdt on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @08:42PM (#39296814)
Is there a rocket equation for bureaucracy? Something to model the exponentially growing efforts of a company that are spent self-support and bureaucracy as the amount of productive work scales up?
Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by ghaff on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @08:55PM (#39296893)
No rocket equation but, if you want to go to the source, see Parkinson's Law (the original essay, not the shorthand aphorism). Which was actually even worse--productive work was not scaling up in the British Navy.

I'm sure there are papers that have studied what happens specifically in business though.

Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by rlanday on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:03AM (#39299489)
Yes, the original Parkinson’s Law paper contains an equation:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson's_Law > The growth was presented mathematically with the formula x = (2k^m + P)/n, in which k was the number of officials wanting subordinates, m was the hours they spent writing minutes to each other.

(check the original paper for details since this obviously doesn’t explain what n is)

Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by neilv on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:24PM (#39297102)
> spherical developers

This could be a physics model, or an imperative to scale back the free food.

Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by Ferret7446 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:11PM (#39298005)
Organizations can't scale linearly. You need more middle managers as you add more people and organizational layers, who don't contribute any "output" so this is trivially true.

Alternatively, you could have thousands of people all reporting to a single manager, and if you think that could work, I have a bridge to sell you.

Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by abkolan on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:24PM (#39298109)
> I mean, LinkedIn has what, 20,000 employees? If you had spherical developers in a vacuum, I doubt you'd need more than 40-50 to maintain their products, but there's more to running a tech company.

This is a ridiculous take. You would need way more than that just to maintain Kafka and run ops for it, that LinkedIn heavily relies on. You are trivializing the complexity of running a platform like LinkedIn.

Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by Nevermark on Thursday February 08, 2024 @10:39AM (#39303172)
Perhaps if reducing the complexity was considered an urgent necessity, over hiring more, there would be less complexity and new opportunities would be easier to consider and jump on.

Complexity compounds, so the tradeoff is, continually tame it, or continually hire with less and less impact per employee.

The latter seems to happen a lot when money flows.

Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by roncesvalles on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:56PM (#39305167)
>I doubt you'd need more than 40-50 to maintain their products

Only if you're certain they will never quit their jobs. In tech where the average tenure is supposedly 2-3 years, a large number of employees are hired to make key persons redundant, groom for succession, and to make sure key persons can offload some bandwidth to work on emergent issues. It's irrational to have billions of dollars of revenue (or even tens of millions) riding on a single person who can decide to walk away with 2 weeks notice.

Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by 23B1 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @08:06PM (#39296555)
Think of google as a gigantic 3D matrix, and you are a node. There's four people surrounding you, and one below, all angling for your budget or job, respectively, and one above you that thinks you're either a threat or chattel.

Your job then becomes CYA in every direction. Ideally you can get a few of your subordinate nodes to work on your project and maybe even do a little CYA for you; the higher you rank, the more nodes you can enlist.

Now add 149,999 nodes.

Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by ghaff on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @08:23PM (#39296677)
There are a lot of things that large organizations can do that smaller ones can not. However, as organizations scale up for good reasons (it takes a lot of people to do some things) and bad (empire building), it takes a lot of people to corral most of those people in productive ways and to support them with all kinds of systems.
Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by shostack on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:56AM (#39298751)
Are there any good examples of this?
Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by buzzerbetrayed on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:47PM (#39297804)
But couldn't the founders put a competent CEO in the chair and still pursue their passion projects on the side?
Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by quatrefoil on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:18PM (#39298062)
Sundar was pretty close to optimal. For internal consumption, it was an inspiring story of an engineer who rose through the ranks to the top, an affirmation of an engineering-centric culture. A foreign-born immigrant to boot.

And for external consumption: a polished, articulate, and presentable exec who can competently testify in front of the Congress or talk to politicians without giving off weird vibes, the way Zuckerberg and some others used to.

Sundar isn't a charismatic leader with a bold vision; he is a bureaucrat. But Google never really had a Jobs-style leader, and that might be fundamentally incompatible with the corporate culture over there. It owed a lot of its early success to great engineering, and the reason it maybe isn't working as well now is mostly a function of size. They used to be content with an innovative project that could bring in $50M... now it's not a success if there's no immediate path to $1B.

It also doesn't help that the company doesn't really have a clear product identity. Apple does consumer hardware and a bunch of services subservient to that. Google is... what? An advertising network? A vendor of office apps for businesses? An ISP? A grocery delivery company (they did that for a good while)? A social network? Oh, and that gaming thing with Stadia? And let's not mention their biotech and self-driving car ventures, now spun off but still paid for from the same coffers... it's admirable that they try so many things, but it makes it hard for them to stick to any long-term plan.

I don't think you can really pin that on Sundar - he didn't create this problem, although to be fair, he's also not fixing it.

Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by dilyevsky on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:40AM (#39298989)
Sundar was never an engineer.

> Google is... what? An advertising network? A vendor of office apps for businesses? An ISP? A grocery delivery company (they did that for a good while)? A social network? Oh, and that gaming thing with Stadia?

There is a clear identity - Google is about hoarding all of the available data (originally web) and making money off of it any way you can. By definition it has to be huge and get their hands into as many pies as humanly possible and then cut away stuff that doesn’t work. So i would say they are being perfectly consistent whether their employees appreciate it or not.

Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by Nevermark on Thursday February 08, 2024 @10:48AM (#39303320)
> making money off of it any way you can

Of course there isn’t an inconsistency there. Its such a non-identity there isn’t anything to be inconsistent with, outside of declaring the company a on-profit.

The problem of lack of identity isn’t always about lack of consistency. It also is a lack of focus.

Lack of focus leaves the door open to vastly increased complexity. The need for more and more employees as per employee impact drops.

Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by dilyevsky on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:18PM (#39304643)
It’s not much more generic than “make consumer electronics” from apple which makes everything under the sun now from headphones to cars. Google just increasingly became at odds with its own “dont be evil” motto as the company had scaled so execution had greately suffered
Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by geodel on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:57PM (#39297892)
Well, if they could've they would've. Also in unlikely case they could've different thinking about competence than yours.
Re:Morale plummets at Google as workers complain bosses are ... by buzzerbetrayed on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:44PM (#39305003)
> Well, if they could've they would've

Um.. that isn't how anything works. Not sure what kind of argument this is