News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As An Author, Why I Truly Hate Ebook DRM by jellicle on Friday May 04, 2012 @12:43PM (#3929213)
You're misunderstanding the purpose of DRM. Every DRM format is cracked within hours of release. The purpose of DRM is not and never has been to stop "pirates".

The purpose of DRM is to get you, the legitimate user, to pay multiple times to use the same content. They want you to pay once to read the book in your kitchen and another time to read the same book in your bedroom and another time if you want to let your wife read it too. By definition, you've already paid once so you're an excellent candidate to get more money out of.

The purpose of DRM is to make it hard for you to use multiple devices, hard for you to use different platforms, and so on. So that you'll pay again. These aren't flaws. They're design goals.

Re:As An Author, Why I Truly Hate Ebook DRM by Fargren on Friday May 04, 2012 @01:59PM (#3929540)
If you are going to make claims that don't agree with what most people believe, you should try to at least provide reasoning behind your theories, if not proof. As it is you are just posting speculation as fact. I think you could make a compelling argument for what you are saying, but you just... aren't.
Re:As An Author, Why I Truly Hate Ebook DRM by bad_user on Friday May 04, 2012 @02:52PM (#3929778)
Some statements are simply obvious and do not need proof.

DRM from a technological perspective is broken, simply because it uses encryption in a wrong way ... the user being both the party that receives the message and the third-party from which the message is protected. This means the decryption key is easily obtained by inspecting the device's memory or hardware or by listening to packets sent over the network. This is why to date there is no DRM scheme that wasn't broken somehow, as the technology is fundamentally flawed from a technical perspective.

For Kindle, here's a collection of 4,687 mostly pirated books in Mobi format that you can copy straight to your device: http://thepiratebay.se/torrent/6748422/Kindle_Library___%284... ... do you really need more proof than this?

Because really, if DRM doesn't protect against piracy, and it doesn't, then what's its purpose, other than lock-in of legitimate customers?

And I've worked for BigCo, I know how they think. Lock-in is not something that just happens. Lock-in is a planned process.

Re:As An Author, Why I Truly Hate Ebook DRM by derefr on Friday May 04, 2012 @08:57PM (#3930982)
> Because really, if DRM doesn't protect against piracy, and it doesn't, then what's its purpose, other than lock-in of legitimate customers?

To give technology partners something (broken) to sell to publishers so they'll agree, in exchange, to publish their catalogue in a digital format. It's like giving someone a (broken) gun so they'll agree to let you go on a date with their daughter. You know it's broken, and they might even know it's broken--but it's the act of doing a "good-faith effort" to protect the publisher's content that matters, not the consequence of whether it gets cracked or not.

Re:As An Author, Why I Truly Hate Ebook DRM by J3L2404 on Friday May 04, 2012 @01:29PM (#3929420)
Sad. I weep for HN.