News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by robomartin on Friday May 04, 2012 @10:26AM (#3928485)
Having participated in conferences in the US and Europe I can say that there are real cost structures to organizing a conference that just can't be avoided. I've done this at venues such as the LA Convention Center, Las Vegas Convention Center, MGM Grand Convention Center, RAI Convention Center (Amsterdam), ICM Munchen (Munich) and various hotels and smaller venues.

In general terms I find the European venues and smaller American or European hotels far more pleasurable, simpler and cheaper to deal with.

The unionized American venues are very expensive and can be a nightmare to deal with. Want coffee in a room for visitors? Sure. It'll be $200 for a gallon. Want a light turned off above a booth? No problem, it'll cost $350 for a union electrician to go to the breaker panel and quite-literally flip a switch. Need to bring some boxes on a dolly to a booth? Can't do it. Once you enter their domain union members need to handle even the most basic of jobs.

In general terms, large venues are expensive, union or not. The union part just skews the cost curve because of how bloated and unreasonable things can become. Add to that insurance, guarantees and other fixed costs and you have a solid formula for high prices for attendees. And, if you are after a venue such as the LV Convention Center, well you'll have to sign a contract and pay a large chunk of money upfront a year ahead of your event.

Then there's the issue that someone alluded to: What do you actually get out of conferences. There are some where you might just meet a person or learn about a technology that is a game changer for whatever it is you are doing. That's priceless and always worth the cost of admission. More often than not, at least in my experience, conferences are very disruptive and do more harm than good. Why?

If you are an exhibitor very soon conferences become these artificial and unreasonable deadlines that almost require you to make announcements. This means that mad scrambles happen around them to get to that point. This can disrupt a company for weeks, both before and after a conference.

As an attendee, you might also delay acting on purchases in order to see the above-mentioned announcements at the conference. The problem is that most conference announcements are vaporware --requiring months of additional work to be real products. By waiting for the next shiny thing you delay your process. And then, of course, there's the huge disruption of sending a whole team to a conference for three to five days --or even more if it requires traveling out of your country.

For a large class of things I have personally found that the quality and depth of information available on the internet is significantly better than what you can get at a conference. I have avoided conferences for three years now, and, I must say, I have learned a lot more, been more productive and made better decisions because of it.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by mjn on Friday May 04, 2012 @10:49AM (#3928600)
I'm not very knowledgeable about this yet, but I'm currently helping to co-organize a conference in Greece, and getting some advice from last year's organizers, who did it in the US, and it's amazing how much of stuff they had to deal with (and pay for) in the US that isn't an issue in Greece. Every little thing was possibly illegal, or if legal, required special approval, approved staff, maybe a permit, extra fees, etc., while in Greece it's one all-inclusive price to rent the venue, which comes with a few staff who'll do reasonable odd jobs. And, they're flexible on us doing outside catering or even doing things ourselves (despite Greece's reputation as a worse place to do business). We can even serve wine ourselves, i.e. literally buy wine from the store, bring it in, and have a table where volunteer conference staff pour it, something that wouldn't fly in the US.
Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by mcguire on Friday May 04, 2012 @11:48AM (#3928906)
Smaller venues in the US are more like that, although I doubt the wine would work. And I've been to one convention (really, that's what these are) at RAI in Amsterdam that was just about as bad as anything I've seen in the US.
Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by huxley on Friday May 04, 2012 @10:52AM (#3928620)
Sadly, it's not just the US. I've helped organized events in Denmark, Spain and China and anything involving hotels or conference centers is horrifying expensive.
Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by eru on Friday May 04, 2012 @10:49AM (#3928602)
I wonder why unions seem to have such horrible effects in the US, while they are comparatively useful in Germany and Scandinavia? Perhaps the explanation for that will also encompass the British unions and Margaret Thatcher?
Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by mjn on Friday May 04, 2012 @10:54AM (#3928638)
I think unions and companies have closer working relationships in Germany and Scandinavia, partly because they start from more similar ideological perspectives. Scandinavian business in particular isn't nearly as hardline market-oriented; they're market-oriented of course, but tend to still use vaguely socialist rhetoric internally, care a lot about projecting a view that they take care of their workers, want to maintain good relations with their unions and avoid conflict, etc. Unions, in the other direction, are also less confrontational, and tend to use back channels and meetings rather than activist measures. The economies overall are sort of run on a general corporatist-consensus model (in the old sense of the word "corporatism"). If that model works badly it could produce corruption and smoky backroom deals, but when run well, I think it tends to produce more commonsense consensus solutions, versus the very legalistic solutions that the American industry-union standoff produces, where everything has to be precisely specified because neither side trusts the other.

One interesting feature is that much of Scandinavia is both more socialist and more marketized than the US. For example, the Danish public-transit system is heavily state-funded, but operated by private contractors, not public-sector employees. The idea seems to be to maintain a high level of public services paid for by taxes, but to actually operate those services via market-based bidding.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by acdha on Friday May 04, 2012 @12:30PM (#3929142)
"partly because they start from more similar ideological perspectives"

I think this is true in the US, unfortunately: the unions and upper management have very similar goals: get paid as much as possible while making as much work as possible someone else's responsibility.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by huggyface on Friday May 04, 2012 @11:16AM (#3928752)
I think unions and companies have closer working relationships in Germany and Scandinavia

The core of this is most certainly true. In North America there is an extremely adversarial atmosphere between unions and workplaces. This leads to the natural result that neither side ever wants to give an inch (the slippery slope principal), and will always try to take an inch, the game leading to the scenarios described.

There is no doubt that the union principal is sound for many professions where power is unbalanced, however the implementation is just completely broken here.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by robomartin on Friday May 04, 2012 @11:27AM (#3928797)
Not sure about Europe. After having dealt with unions in the US for quite some time my general opinion of the average unionized worker is not very kind: lazy, non-productive, selfish, self-important, over-paid, unfairly protected, de-humanized, and more.

Of course, this is a gross over-simplification and a generalization that is not fair to a lot of people. There are good unionized workers.

I'll give you an example: Las Vegas Convention Center. Doing some work at night setting up computers, etc. The crew that installs the carpets comes in. Their job is, quite literally, to roll out the carpeting. I watched as this unfolded. Every hour or so a supervisor would roll around on a little electric cart and would tell people that they had to take a break. The workers would lay down on the carpet and go to sleep. This ballet continued for hours. The work that could have been done in three hours too six, if not more. I asked one of them how much they made. She, very proudly replied: $45 per hour plus benefits and a pension plan. My jaw dropped.

Then there are the stories of the security guards making $150K a year to sit on a chair by a door. And the stories of the union worker refusing to lend a hand because the task is not in their union contract.

Anyhow, the issue, as I see it, is that unions have resulted in hordes of people that are devoid of any real drive to succeed and move forward in life. In unions there are few incentives to be better at what you do. In a lot of union contracts you just can't be fired. I mean, take the examples of (unionized) teachers sexually assaulting students. They don't get fired, they are transfered and "hidden" in another job. There was a recent case of a (unionized) teacher who was feeding his students cookies with semen on on top. That's beyond sick. And, as I understand it, the guy was not fired and will enjoy his 80% pension for the rest of his life.

Anyhow, I don't want to go off on that tangent, but I've just seen too many examples where unions are just destroying drive, innovation and competitiveness in this country. It's a damn shame.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by huxley on Friday May 04, 2012 @12:20PM (#3929079)
People usually treat venue staff like crap, so it's no wonder that they might be surly. They are anticipating prima donnas walking in and screaming at them (and they do).

When you bring a big event to a venue you are creating an immense amount of work. You're only there for a short time, you show up for a few days and then leave. They're there all the time. A janitor can make or break your conference. Can you imagine what 1500 people do to a venues' washrooms?

Before our events, we always go and introduce ourselves to the staff. We try to keep things friendly and it's always paid off for us. I hand out my business cards to every staff member from hotel clerks to cleaners to security guards. If they have any problems or questions, they have my personal cell number to call.

If we have pizza brought in for the volunteers, we always offer some to the shift workers there. We try to be pleasant and courteous to the staff ahead of time, you won't believe what a huge difference it makes.

On the 2nd day of our last event, one of the security guards bought me a screwdriver set out of his own money because he saw we needed one. Doesn't always happen but people can surprise you.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by drumdance on Friday May 04, 2012 @02:26PM (#3929656)
It's good that you make the extra effort, but it's not like these people are waiters that make their living from tips. I work a lot too and sometimes get frustrated with customers, but that doesn't give me license to treat them like crap.
Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by huxley on Friday May 04, 2012 @03:22PM (#3929911)
Well, we're all the protagonists of our own story. I'm sure some people think I'm a surly bastard.

My job can be pretty stressful too, but I rarely have to deal with a washroom stall covered in filth from the most disturbing case of explosive diarrhea ever.

Likewise I'm not usually expected to escort out a distraught, screaming homeless person who is having a psychotic episode in the middle of a busy convention center.

Hakuna Matata.

Just assume someone has dealt with something like that or worse and it gets easier to be nice to them, even when they're behaving like right old pricks.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by marcusf on Friday May 04, 2012 @05:24PM (#3930416)
This might be OT, but you seem like a very good guy. I've no deeper insight to offer than that, just wanted to say it.
Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by smackfu on Friday May 04, 2012 @11:41AM (#3928872)
Given that the goal of the union is to organize the workers so they get better working conditions and pay and can't be arbitrarily fired, it seems to be working just fine.

If you thought you were underpaid, and you unionized to get a better rate, I bet your customers would bitch about it too and blame the union.

And at heart, your complaint is really that management did a poor job of negotiating a contract with the union.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by robomartin on Friday May 04, 2012 @01:31PM (#3929425)
I don't know why you were downvoted, I gave you on upvote.

You are, of course, absolutely correct at some level. I think that in the vast majority of cases it isn't union membership that is evil but rather the union bosses and negotiators that set out to suck the blood right out of the businesses they deal with.

It's no different than politics. The union bosses have a nice ride and want to keep it. If they keep providing for the membership they gain votes and stay in power. Damn the consequences. And, when you join unions with governments you have the perfect storm: sharks vs. weasels. The union negotiators are the sharks intent in obtaining as much as they can out of the government agency. The government folks want the votes from the union membership. So, they, effectively, pay them off to buy their votes by granting all kinds of insane things to the union sharks. How else would you have a librarian retire and be paid $250K a year for life?

These costs, be them in the private domain or government have to come from somewhere. In the case of conferences it makes everything more expensive for attendees.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by huxley on Friday May 04, 2012 @03:29PM (#3929933)
Where do you live so I can get one of those sweet jobs?

Jeez, the Dean of the University Libraries in University Of Southern California pulls down $250,000, but you do know that isn't really a common thing?

Median salary for librarians is about $50,000, which isn't bad but not "retire on $250K for life".

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by smackfu on Monday May 07, 2012 @01:19PM (#3939930)
And "librarian" covers a whole lot of ground. Here is the UConn list of job families: http://www.hr.uconn.edu/employment_services/ucpea_salary.htm...

A person you or I would call a librarian can be classed anywhere from UCP V to UCP X, which covers a salary range of $40k to $110k.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by MaysonL on Friday May 04, 2012 @06:40PM (#3930652)
University of Southern California (USC) is a private university.
Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by huxley on Sunday May 06, 2012 @09:04PM (#3937076)
Fair enough but my point was that if there are librarians that make $250,000 it is because they are at the highest level of administration over a library system, not the librarians that you meet at a reference desk.

As eli_gottlieb pointed out, many librarian positions are unpaid so the $50K figure may significantly overestimate the salary of a librarian if volunteer ones are not counted.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by eli_gottlieb on Saturday May 05, 2012 @02:03AM (#3931485)
I don't know if that number is accurate. Many librarian positions are unpaid nowadays...
Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by meej on Monday May 07, 2012 @01:42PM (#3940056)
I completed an MSLIS degree in 2008. My classmates who were bound for traditional library careers used to joke that the only masters-level degree that pays less after graduation is Social Work.

The WSJ published a sortable table of unemployment and salaries by degree late last year. Library Science graduates currently face an unemployment rate of 15% in the field (4th highest, out of 173 degrees) and salaries that rank in the bottom 5 amongst all degrees. http://graphicsweb.wsj.com/documents/NILF1111/#term=

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by wpietri on Friday May 04, 2012 @04:09PM (#3930120)
I wouldn't just blame the unions there. In the places that I've seen this dynamic, it's paired with exploitative management.

Without the unions, the managers would be running people ragged in the name of profit. So the natural counter-reaction is FU, I'll do as little as possible for the dough. Totally pathological, but in high school I had a couple of shitty minimum wage jobs that put me in that mindset.

For those interested in the dynamic, I strongly recommend the "This American Life" episode NUMMI:

http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/403/n...

It describes one of GM's worst plants switching over to a Toyota joint venture. Same people, but it went from this kind of bullshit (and worse!) to a place that everybody loved and worked hard at.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by goostavos on Saturday May 05, 2012 @03:44PM (#3933048)
>the average unionized worker is not very kind: lazy, non-productive, selfish, self-important, over-paid, unfairly protected, de-humanized, and more.

I could not agree more. Unionized workers make my life hell anytime I'm in Vegas or Philly -- With Philly being an order of magnitude worse.

The first time I worked in Philly was a rage-inducing experience. We were forced to pay an "A/V" guy $40 an hour to sit in a room all day and do absolutely nothing. I set everything that needed setup the night before the conference, but because we were filming in one of 'their' rooms, we were legally obligated to hire a local guy. And since there was nothing for him to do, that fucker would show up in the morning with his laptop, sit down in a corner, and play fucking games all day.

For the full 5 days of shooting, we only asked him to do one thing -- one -- and that was to bring us a handheld recorder we left in one of the rooms. Could he? "No, I technically can't because it's the end of the day".

Though, over the years I've learned that sending them to a corner all day is ultimately the best option. The are lazy, unreliable, and FAR too technically incompetent to perform the work asked of them.

We are often tasked with recording entire conferences. For really large events, in the area of 25-30 concurrent sessions per hour, it is generally expected that out of the hundreds of final sessions, one or two will be lost due to gear failures or non-compliant speakers. 2 out of 400 is not bad. However, using local union help? That number balloons to unreasonable. We've at times lost upwards of 30% of the sessions slated to be recorded. Which of course makes us look incapable of doing our job, which affects repeat business. It sucks.

It's infuriating as a small business to be forced to hire people that will only damage our business. It's completely anti-competitive.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by huxley on Friday May 04, 2012 @11:08AM (#3928704)
It's not really the unions, it's just markup the venues charge on everything.

The worker is likely part of the regular physical plant run by the venue and it is cheaper for the venue to have someone on staff to fix things. The electrician is on salary or steady wages.

Each $350 fee likely pays for most of the electrician's wages for that day, so if you have 20 rooms that need electrical drops, you are paying 10-20x the cost of the electrician and assistants.

You as an event organizer don't have a choice about whether you need electrical power for a room so you are a trapped consumer. And the venues take advantage of that.

This is made worse because of the economic distortion caused by Pharmaceutical or Medical conferences which are so flush with money that $350 for an electrical drop is inconsequential. There are conferences where they'll set off indoor fireworks and hire professional musicians to write songs for the event.

The venues get accustomed to event planners that write checks for every problem, so if you are running a conference for people like geeks or academics who may not be as lucrative, you pay through the nose.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by smackfu on Friday May 04, 2012 @11:33AM (#3928823)
Yes, the unions are partly just getting caught in the middle. They may have a high hourly wage, but that's all they set, and it's certainly not $250 an hour. The convention center is taking the money and the union is getting the blame.

OTOH, it is true that the union will aggressively police their job roles, which may have expanded over time to include things that are just silly, like moving a cart from A to B. Ideally those would be rolled back to sensible jobs that require workers, but obviously no one has an incentive to do that.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by specialist on Friday May 04, 2012 @02:17PM (#3929622)
I was the IT guy for an electrical contractor. I observed the benefit of having set roles.

You need fiber spliced? Call the union hall and ask for that skill and they'll send you a worker that absolutely will be able to do that specific task. The benefit of outsourcing the vetting, training, and qualifications to the union hall was huge. (And better than any temp agency I've ever seen or heard about.)

In other professions, I have no doubt that silly shop floors rules (need an elevator operator to work the elevator) are terrible. I've heard the stories, many by union members that disagree.

My guess is those silly rules start as buyoffs / payola (quid pro quo during some negotation years ago) and became institutionalized.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by MaysonL on Friday May 04, 2012 @06:37PM (#3930640)
Because they had to fight so hard to exist at all here, and were often brutalized by police and/or private thugs, and the memories linger, making them fight for everything they can get. In Germany and Scandinavia, most of the unions seem to see their relationship with employers more as a partnership than a zero-sum competition.
Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by daniel-cussen on Friday May 04, 2012 @11:17PM (#3931219)
I think Northern European culture makes it difficult for people to live with themselves if they're slacking off. It's built into many kinds of Protestantism and may have cultural inertia in places (like Sweden) with more atheist leanings.
Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by rmason on Friday May 04, 2012 @12:54PM (#3929282)
I think smart planning can help you avoid most of the problems. I have attended an open source conference the past two years and the tickets were $72 for three days and the speakers were excellent.

It was held in a new hotel in Dallas and the rooms were all $99 a night. I'm not sure how they did it but I am witness to the fact that it can be done.

Source: http://www.opencfsummit.org/

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by huxley on Friday May 04, 2012 @03:41PM (#3929998)
Having the event in February helps. Off-season and it's not in Dallas itself, but in Garland.

If you're flexible about the when and where, you can get a decent price. Lots of events don't have that flexibility.

Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by PonyGumbo on Friday May 04, 2012 @04:51PM (#3930310)
I was a conference director for seven years, and everything you say is true. In addition to what you mentioned, conference organizers are forced to estimate the number of attendees and reserve blocks of hotel rooms to ensure availability. In most cases, you're doing this eight months in advance - before any of the speakers have been selected. If you fail to hit your room night reserve, you pay out the nose.
Re:Overpriced Developer Conferences by nirvana on Friday May 04, 2012 @10:38AM (#3928555)
Agreed. I remember, back in the day, having to sneak our computers in because the "union method" was to leave the $50,000 of SGI workstations we were using for our demo on a cart, unattended, for several hours, until someone could get around to rolling it to our booth. We'd already heard from some people about equipment getting stolen. The union guys were spending more time making sure people weren't sneaking their stuff into the conference venue than... moving stuff into the conference venue (and these machines were on loan to begin with.)

If you wanted to hire labor, being forced to hire the union because they have a deal wit the conference center would be one thing, but being forced to hire them when you would prefer to do it yourself, is completely different.

Plus, these days, you no longer need to all show up at the same place at the same time to transmit specialized information. This is why the conference industry is seemingly dying.

I stopped going to WWDC simply because it was such a massive hassle, and WWDC is a fantastic conference. I started buying the Videos (which Apple now makes available for free)... it is much cheaper and less hassle to spend the $600 on the videos they charged when they were charging for them.