News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New IBM LinuxONE 4 Express – Rack-mounted pre-configured ... by sonnyOrullivan on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @04:51PM (#39281195)
> Consider that partitions are completely isolated from each other. Not some pesky soft isolation either, it's all done in hardware. In practice, every partition in a mainframe is a different logical yet isolated mainframe.

"Completely isolated in hardware" as in isolated by a software hypervisor (PR/SM) that doesn't have a whole lot of hardware support?

> Mainframes are built for different kinds of workloads. They are not cloud machines. They are batch machines with 6 or more nines of uptime.

That's kind of the point. What exactly is the niche, i.e. which new customer with exactly what software and latency requirements would switch from their current system to a z? IBM won't tell you apart from buzzword bingo.

Re:New IBM LinuxONE 4 Express – Rack-mounted pre-configured ... by fuzztester on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @05:24PM (#39281634)
>buzzword bingo

I'm guessing that many of the terms in this thread are buzzwords for many of us reading it :), since relatively few people work on mainframes.

I had not heard of the term buzzword bingo before, so I googled it:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buzzword_bingo

Interesting. It aligns with my corporate experience in a few cases.

Re:New IBM LinuxONE 4 Express – Rack-mounted pre-configured ... by 20after4 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:33AM (#39286840)
Re:New IBM LinuxONE 4 Express – Rack-mounted pre-configured ... by rbanffy on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @04:04PM (#39294303)
Re:New IBM LinuxONE 4 Express – Rack-mounted pre-configured ... by fuzztester on Thursday February 08, 2024 @06:23PM (#39309216)
Wow. She nails his guff at the end, with one single word.

I'm nominating this video for the next Oscars, Grammies, or whatever the heck the movie awards are called (I don't keep track of such stuff). Bet it'll win gold in the under-1-minute category ;)

Re:New IBM LinuxONE 4 Express – Rack-mounted pre-configured ... by rbanffy on Friday February 09, 2024 @06:54AM (#39313887)
That campaign probably got a truckload of awards in Cannes. I was working at Ogilvy back then and IBM was one huge client of ours.
Re:New IBM LinuxONE 4 Express – Rack-mounted pre-configured ... by fuzztester on Sunday February 11, 2024 @03:37AM (#39333467)
Oh, wow. I have read his book, Ogilvy on Advertising. Found it interesting, to say the least.
Re:New IBM LinuxONE 4 Express – Rack-mounted pre-configured ... by wolverine876 on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @09:18PM (#39283678)
> "Completely isolated in hardware" as in isolated by a software hypervisor (PR/SM) that doesn't have a whole lot of hardware support?

Are you saying the GP's statement is outright false?

Re:New IBM LinuxONE 4 Express – Rack-mounted pre-configured ... by rodgerd on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @10:47PM (#39284256)
It is extremely optimistic, to put it mildly. You can definitely get inter-LPAR noise. I've seen it first hand, personally, on systems that I've worked on.

Moreover the norm for zLinux system is to isolate guests with zVM, not LPARs. LPARs are more likely to be boundaries for chunkier workload definitions - that advice may have changed since I last cracked open a redbook; zVM offers similar isolation to what you'd see with KVM, VMWare, or other hardware-assisted hypervisors.

Re:New IBM LinuxONE 4 Express – Rack-mounted pre-configured ... by prng2021 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:14AM (#39284770)
Read chapter 3 here: https://www.redbooks.ibm.com/redbooks/pdfs/sg248233.pdf#page...

They’ve spent the last 60 years developing and refining everything for extreme levels of uptime and high availability. It’s truly unique to these mainframes because IBM controls every aspect of it. The closest equivalent of that kind of vertical integration is your Macbook Pro.

I highly doubt there are any brand new mainframe customers these days. But many of the biggest companies you know and use every single day have tons of workloads that will never move off of it.

Re:New IBM LinuxONE 4 Express – Rack-mounted pre-configured ... by sonnyOrullivan on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:14AM (#39286704)
I don't think I need to be reading this. The uptime and several 9s of high availability are attainable with z/OS and a parallel sysplex. No doubt systems like these are used by banks and others in the wild.

But this doesn't say anything about "unbelievably powerful" or "feature-full" as in the OP?

The niche customer claim probably is "will never move off of it because nobody ever wants to touch millions of lines of COBOL" then that's fine. It's likely sane from a business perspective to continue using them as long as maintenance burden is manageable. Luckily managers in those more conservative companies consider full rewrites dangerous, rightly so. But in order to claim otherwise (i.e. unbelievably powerful and thus for everybody) we need to see numbers.

Re:New IBM LinuxONE 4 Express – Rack-mounted pre-configured ... by prng2021 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:43AM (#39289140)
I’d say 15+ years ago, they were very powerful relative to other solutions on the market during those times. But I agree that’s no longer the case when compared to modern server racks.

I pointed out that Redbook about HA features since it’s a major differentiator of mainframes even today, but there are also these that document other features:

https://www.redbooks.ibm.com/redbooks/pdfs/sg248950.pdf#page...

https://www.redbooks.ibm.com/redbooks/pdfs/sg246366.pdf#page...

You can find 1 or more books that go into a deep dive of every chapter.

IBM has taken input from the biggest companies in the world over many decades to run as many of their workloads as possible. They’ve honed everything in their software and hardware to do so, down to developing specific cpu instructions to support specific use cases. If all of this doesn’t convey an extremely feature rich system, I’d like to hear why you think otherwise.