Re:We Can't Have Nice Software
by krunck on Monday February 05, 2024 @03:36PM
(#39266796)
It's just a hit-piece against new tech: blockchain-based systems and LLM. Move along, nothing to see.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:We Can't Have Nice Software
by hscontinuity on Monday February 05, 2024 @04:03PM
(#39267137)
While it may be a hit piece, I certainly understand the validity in the philosophical nature behind the ideology.
I reflect similarly in my own observations in general. We often foresee the future as a reflection of 'here and now' versus understanding the long-term implications of decisions made at vast scale.
There are many great examples right in plain sight in every day life.
Re:We Can't Have Nice Software
by mmcdermott on Monday February 05, 2024 @05:46PM
(#39268270)
I'm not so sure. Those technologies are lampooned, but in the context of a broader point, namely that software requires ever more effort to deliver results that are not objectively better. I think that observation is valid and interesting to consider, though the rest of the essay is all over the place.
Re:We Can't Have Nice Software
by grayhatter on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:57PM
(#39268898)
A hit piece is something written to intentionally degrade something. You can have a hit piece for Bitcoin, but not some technology. You can have a hit piece attacking someone who uses technology. But for that specific use, you wouldn't try to explain the idea as a thread through many different examples across many different separate engineering domains. This isn't a hit peice about your favorite flavor of tech, it's a "hit piece" about a new-enough trend that's appeared in SWE, it's a disagreement about an idea... more commonly referred to as, an opinion.
but you're right, opinions you don't agree with are dangerous.