News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Psychology, a Failed Discipline: Flawed Paradigms, Method... by umvi on Sunday February 04, 2024 @01:36PM (#39252990)
Debugging skills learned from software development are highly applicable for troubleshooting mechanical (car) and even medical problems so it's hard to take professionals in other fields seriously when they lack the same debugging ability.

I've taken my car into the mechanic before only to be told the problem isn't reproducible so then I eliminate variables to figure it out myself and essentially do their job for them. Once I enumerate exactly how to reproduce, it's all but clear what the problem is and then they can replace the part.

Re:Psychology, a Failed Discipline: Flawed Paradigms, Method... by chefandy on Sunday February 04, 2024 @01:38PM (#39253002)
> Debugging skills learned from software development are highly applicable for troubleshooting mechanical (car) and even medical problems so it's hard to take professionals other fields seriously when they lack the same debugging ability.

I'm positive it wasn't intentional, but you've done a fine job buttressing my argument.

Re:Psychology, a Failed Discipline: Flawed Paradigms, Method... by umvi on Sunday February 04, 2024 @01:45PM (#39253067)
True or false: An above average software developer that is good at debugging probably really is better at troubleshooting mechanical or medical problems than an average or below average mechanic or doctor?

So then the problem may be that average software developers overestimate their own ability ;)

Re:Psychology, a Failed Discipline: Flawed Paradigms, Method... by hunter-gatherer on Sunday February 04, 2024 @02:17PM (#39253407)
Are you being serious right now? Have you tallied the number of times you've outsmarted someone of another profession. Maybe you know more than you think you do about auto repair???
Re:Psychology, a Failed Discipline: Flawed Paradigms, Method... by wolverine876 on Sunday February 04, 2024 @03:13PM (#39253917)
There's a strong bias toward confirmation. First, they fully expect it and are looking for it.

Most of all, the actual professional - like any professional - has learned that it's unproductive to debate or educate the patient/customer; you just let them think they're smart and work around it. It's not your job to teach them the error of their ways, but to get your work done.

In IT, I've had plenty of clients tell me the most ludicrous nonsense. You just work around it; IT is your job, not theirs; don't humiliate them. Be respectful to people; they have hard days too.

Re:Psychology, a Failed Discipline: Flawed Paradigms, Method... by umvi on Sunday February 04, 2024 @05:28PM (#39255180)
That's true, I haven't counted all the times the mechanic or doctor did their job well.

I just tend to remember the times where they didn't do their job well. For example, my daughter had a rash, the doctor says to just put moisturizer on it. Doesn't seem to help so I research it for a few hours on google and conclude it's shingles. The doctor scoffs at my suggestion saying my daughter is way too young to have shingles and says to just continue with the moisturizer. We take her to a second doctor who confirms it's shingles.

So yes, I would admit my anecdotes are probably a form of survivorship bias and I'm letting a few incompetent doctors and mechanics taint the ability of their peers.

Re:Psychology, a Failed Discipline: Flawed Paradigms, Method... by chefandy on Sunday February 04, 2024 @02:08PM (#39253302)
> True or false: An above average software developer that is good at debugging probably really is better at troubleshooting mechanical or medical problems than an average or below average mechanic or doctor? > So then the problem may be that average software developers overestimate their own ability ;)

Some really good evidence that the answer is "false" is that developers who think it's true will use a handful of personal experiences to levy sweeping judgements about millions of people in a vast array of disciplines, many of which tackle some of the hardest problems humanity has ever undertaken in fields that dwarf the complexity of computer science immeasurably.

Re:Psychology, a Failed Discipline: Flawed Paradigms, Method... by cornstalks on Sunday February 04, 2024 @02:12PM (#39253345)
False. Definitely false.

And I say this as an above average software developer (which sounds stupidly cocky to even say).

Re:Psychology, a Failed Discipline: Flawed Paradigms, Method... by actuallyalys on Sunday February 04, 2024 @02:16PM (#39253400)
Debugging skills transfer somewhat to solving problems in other domains. However, the reverse is also true and also you often need substantial expertise to actually apply your debugging skills.

Honestly I could imagine a mechanic writing the opposite sentiment, saying they don’t respect software developers because they called a support line and the only advice was to restart the computer and then to reinstall it from scratch.

Re:Psychology, a Failed Discipline: Flawed Paradigms, Method... by chefandy on Sunday February 04, 2024 @02:51PM (#39253699)
> Honestly I could imagine a mechanic writing the opposite sentiment

Coming from working class social/work/familial environments, I know this archetype well: John Ratzenberger's "Cliff Clavin" from Cheers. It's a dated reference, but it fits really well. The stereotype involves carrying large rings of keys on their belts, showing that they're entrusted with many valuable things, and frequently interjecting others conversations with things like "let me show you out to use that thing [blue smoke]" and "no no no you got it all wrong. What you gotta do is..."

In fact, I knew a particularly untalented auto mechanic who insisted that his capability was equivalent to a mechanical engineer when sadly, it wasn't even equivalent to most mechanics. None of us perfectly gauges our capabilities relative others, but some are so very much worse at it.