News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, ... by uptown on Friday February 02, 2024 @10:57AM (#39230077)
I'm fairly tuned into news -- certainly less-so than in the past, but somehow I never even heard of The Messenger.
Re:Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, ... by CommieBobDole on Friday February 02, 2024 @11:41AM (#39230777)
Yep, I read the news every day, subscribe to several news outlets, keep up with the various issues going on, am even somewhat tangentially aware of the various meta-drama going on in journalism circles, and the shutdown announcement is the first I've ever heard of The Messenger.

Whatever they were spending their money on, it certainly wasn't marketing.

Re:Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, ... by basch on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:42PM (#39233181)
I would like some kind of tool that watches for new publications, maybe some objective ranking on popularity and subjective ranking on quality, and an associated graveyard that switches to archival links.

It also needs a slider, to see the historical version of a leaderboard on any given day. You can plug the redef and techmeme leaderboards into archive.org but it is all a little kludgy, with missing data.

https://redef.com/charts/sources/total

https://www.techmeme.com/lb

https://mediagazer.com/lb

https://www.memeorandum.com/lb

There is also

https://longform.org/archive/publications

https://www.aldaily.com/media/

There used to be https://www.newswhip.com/ which had a free section, Im not sure if it is gone or just burried. At one point Counterparties https://www.niemanlab.org/2011/09/felix-salmons-brain-drudge... which used https://percolate.com/ (now seismic) as a backend.

And then you have the world of blogger, medium, substack, ghost. Bloglovin was the site in that realm back in the day.

Re:Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, ... by taeric on Friday February 02, 2024 @11:06AM (#39230214)
Same. Feels a lot like insider gossip that thought they had more going for themselves?

That said, "It’s a radical idea, but we could make meaningful progress if we clawed journalism from the hands of affluent, out of touch brunchlords, and put it back under the control of diverse, hungry journalists and editors who actually understand the news industry and media environment they work and exist in." is also a rather boring take? What do they want to make "meaningful progress" on? I certainly can't see "journalism for journalism's sake" as a good thing. Seems more likely you will get gatekeeping and another venue for activism?

Re:Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, ... by dihydro on Friday February 02, 2024 @11:30AM (#39230597)
In my opinion, "journalism for journalism's sake" would be what we call reporting the truth, or investigative journalism. Is there a national outlet that invests in pure investigative journalism anymore?
Re:Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, ... by tivert on Friday February 02, 2024 @12:17PM (#39231308)
>> What do they want to make "meaningful progress" on? I certainly can't see "journalism for journalism's sake" as a good thing. Seems more likely you will get gatekeeping and another venue for activism?

> In my opinion, "journalism for journalism's sake" would be what we call reporting the truth, or investigative journalism. Is there a national outlet that invests in pure investigative journalism anymore?

Investigative journalism can still amount to "gatekeeping and another venue for activism," if the investigative attention is selective and focused (more or less) to support one or more activist programs.

That's actually the most effective kind of manipulation, because it's simultaneously true and misleading.

And I also think that's close to what we've got. To really be "journalism for journalism's sake," I think you'd have to allocated investigative resources roughly equally among factions, with investigations focused on "pro-narrative" ideas and "counter-narrative" ideas.

Re:Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, ... by taeric on Friday February 02, 2024 @11:53AM (#39230968)
That is the noble way to consider it, but as soon as something starts existing for its own sake, you start losing the reason the thing was enacted the first time.

I'd hazard the "pure" journalism you are seeing in your mind likely wasn't nearly as pure as you'd think it was. There is a reason a lot of very long lived scandals have always been the case. Even more true as you consider news crossing country boundaries. Any specific examples you have in mind?

Re:Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, ... by seanicus on Friday February 02, 2024 @11:50AM (#39230915)
If you're looking for investigative journalism The Intercept isn't a bad read
Re:Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, ... by slowmovintarget on Monday February 05, 2024 @03:44PM (#39266890)
The big stories used to be broken by local newspaper reporters. That process has been deliberately broken by private equity.

So... No, sadly.