Re:ISPs Improve Their DNS Hijacking And How To Stop It
by netdog on Wednesday May 02, 2012 @10:22PM
(#3922106)
You might be surprised to learn that the Internet Protocol and the DNS are used for many other things besides serving web pages to browsers.
Re:ISPs Improve Their DNS Hijacking And How To Stop It
by Anderkent on Thursday May 03, 2012 @09:24AM
(#3923709)
They want to see a useful message from their browser, like:
This page does not exist. Did you mean '...'?
Which most modern browsers give them provided their ISP does not hijack the NX response to present their ads.
Re:ISPs Improve Their DNS Hijacking And How To Stop It
by pbhjpbhj on Friday May 04, 2012 @01:20PM
(#3929378)
Except that's what the ISP, or DNS provider, is providing - a page indicating the domain isnt there and giving other options.
Re:ISPs Improve Their DNS Hijacking And How To Stop It
by mikeash on Wednesday May 02, 2012 @09:39PM
(#3922014)
If users want that, it can and should be solved in the client instead. One of the really nasty things about ISPs doing this is that it actively prevents clients from doing it, since they can no longer easily identify a nonexistent domain.
Re:ISPs Improve Their DNS Hijacking And How To Stop It
by angersock on Wednesday May 02, 2012 @10:50PM
(#3922171)
You're silly, that's silly--stop being silly.
This "average user"? Frankly, we've had the 'net for like fifteen years--now's a good a time for users to learn as any.
Unless, of course, you prefer to spoonfeed the next generation of consumer whores?
Re:ISPs Improve Their DNS Hijacking And How To Stop It
by pbhjpbhj on Friday May 04, 2012 @01:32PM
(#3929426)
We're talking about a barely vsible change for most users in which instead of having to retype a domain or repeat a search when the domain name is a typo (or the domain has closed) a list akin to a SERP is provided.
User make mistakes, domains are abandoned - for those cases this provides a simple service which reduces user effort.
Do I want to spoonfeed a generation of consumer whores? Would love to. But I suspect they like errant toddlers would spit out my message of anti-consumerism, sustainability, social action, fair trade ...
No it isn't yours in an extreme minority edge case compared to most internet users. Users don't want a blank page with just a weird code on it.
They want links to click to get to the page that they meant to type in, or failing that a similar page link supplied by their ISP ...