News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Makes for 'Good' Mathematics? by isilofi on Thursday February 01, 2024 @11:38AM (#39217845)
Good Mathematics doesn't use the axiom of choice.
Re:What Makes for 'Good' Mathematics? by IngoBlechschmid on Thursday February 01, 2024 @12:14PM (#39218358)
I agree, the axiom of choice disincentives us from striving for more elegant solutions.

That said, the axiom of choice is always available in Gödel's sandbox of "constructible sets", and by "Shoenfield absoluteness", some results can escape the sandbox.

For instance, the result that every vector space has a basis is equivalent to the axiom of choice. We have it in Gödel's sandbox and we don't have it outside, if we prefer to not use the axiom of choice in our meta theory. But every purely number-theoretic consequence of that result flows from the sandbox to the ambient universe.

In this sense, the axiom of choice can be regarded as a useful fiction. Not necessarily true in a literal sense, but true enough for many purposes.

I gave a 37c3 talk on this topic: https://www.speicherleck.de/iblech/stuff/37c3-axiom-of-choic...

Re:What Makes for 'Good' Mathematics? by j2kun on Thursday February 01, 2024 @11:41AM (#39217909)
In undergrad my friends and I made a shirt:

   Pro-axiom of choice
   Because every vector space deserves a basis
Re:What Makes for 'Good' Mathematics? by tux3 on Thursday February 01, 2024 @11:58AM (#39218133)
Something bothers about some of the special cases, but I can't quite describe it.
Re:What Makes for 'Good' Mathematics? by candlemas on Thursday February 01, 2024 @02:22PM (#39220031)
The axiom of choice should be considered supernatural.