Re:Getting fitter can reduce prostate cancer risk by 35%, st...
by zeteo on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @07:06AM
(#39202796)
Isn't it the same with exercise, though?
> Those who you see exercising are likely quite healthy and thus _able_ to exercise to old age (or won a genetic lottery to be able to withstand a lot of exercising).
> What you need to count is how many people try to exercise, and then the % of them dying earlier than those who don't
Re:Getting fitter can reduce prostate cancer risk by 35%, st...
by chii on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @09:26AM
(#39204156)
It's not exactly the same, because there's actually studies that tries to answer this exact question - https://youtu.be/-3dt7rpvz4g?t=294
TLDW; the curve of risk/mortality vs amount of exercise is a u-shaped curve, which means if you _don't_ exercise, you also die earlier, and if exercised _too much_ , you also die earlier.
it's quite a sample bias, because those who you see smoking are likely quite healthy and thus is _able_ to smoke to old age (or won a genetic lottery to be able to withstand smoking).
What you need to count is how many people smoke, and then the % of them dying earlier than those who don't. Otherwise, sample bias will give you the wrong conclusions, esp. if this bias is affirming your own world view.