News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel's Humbling by mise_en_place on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @10:01PM (#39199272)
Intel pivoting to GPUs was a smart move but they just lacked the tribal knowledge needed to successfully ship a competitive GPU offering. We got Arc instead.
Re:Intel's Humbling by solarkraft on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @10:34PM (#39199515)
Isn't Arc actually pretty okay?
Re:Intel's Humbling by mastax on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:27PM (#39199918)
They mostly work now and they are decent options at the low-end (what used to be the mid-range: $200) where there is shockingly little competition nowadays.

However, they underperform greatly compared to competitors' cards with similar die areas and memory bus widths. For example the Arc A770 is 406mm^2 on TSMC N6 and a 256-bit bus and performs similarly to the RX 6650XT which is 237mm^2 on TSMC N7 with a 128-bit bus. They're probably losing a lot of money on these cards.

Re:Intel's Humbling by inversetelecine on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @10:55PM (#39199675)
It's getting better and drivers are improving all the time. I personally liked the Arc for the hardware AV1 encoding. Quicksync (I use qsvencc) is actually pretty decent for a hardware encoder. It won't ever beat software encoding, but the speed is hard to ignore. I don't have any experience using it for streaming, but it seems pretty popular there too. Nvidia has nvenc, and reviews say it's good as well but I've never used it.
Re:Intel's Humbling by FullyFunctional on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:57PM (#39200118)
This. If you follow GamersNexus, there are stories every month about just how much the Arc drivers have improved. If this rate continues and the next-gen hardware (Battlemage) actually ships, then Intel might be a serious contender for the midrange. I really hope Intel sticks with it this time as we all know it takes monumental effort to enter the discrete GPU market.
Re:Intel's Humbling by dralley on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @10:56PM (#39199683)
When it works, perhaps
Re:Intel's Humbling by mjevans on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:02PM (#39199736)
Arc seems more like, where the GPU will 'be' in another 2-6 years. Where Arc's second or third iteration might be more competitive. Vulkan / future focused, fast enough that some translation layers for old <= DX11 / OpenGL are worth it.

If you're hoping for an nVidia competitor, the units in that market may be more per unit, but there's already an 1-ton gorilla there and AMD can't seem to compete either. Rather, Arc makes sense as an in-house GPU unit to pair with existing silicon (CPUs) and low / mid range dGPUs to compete where nVidia's left that market and where AMD has a lot of lunch to undercut.

Re:Intel's Humbling by moondev on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @12:02AM (#39200163)
One unfortunate note on Nvidia data center GPUs is to fully utilize features such as vgpu and multi-instance GPU, there is an ongoing licensing fee for the drivers.

I applaud Intel for providing fully capable drivers at no additional cost. Combined with better availability for purchase they are competing in the VDI space.

https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/products/docs/discre...