Re:Oxide Computer releases distribution of illumos intended ...
by bbkane on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @01:12AM
(#39186899)
I'd like to learn DTrace (especially after the recent 20yr podcast episode), but I worry it'll never make into mainstream Linux debugging, and hence only useful for more niche jobs.
Re:Oxide Computer releases distribution of illumos intended ...
by sunshowers on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @02:15PM
(#39194329)
Your concern is completely reasonable -- a thing I'd add though is that both Windows and macOS have DTrace support.
Re:Oxide Computer releases distribution of illumos intended ...
by bbkane on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @02:49PM
(#39194779)
I was excited, but it looks like both MacOS and Windows require special admin permissions for my laptop that I doubt my work would approve (completely reasonable to require this, it just makes it unusable for me).
Re:Oxide Computer releases distribution of illumos intended ...
by 4ad on Saturday February 03, 2024 @08:58AM
(#39240378)
It's actually not reasonable to require this if you do it right. On Solaris and illumos DTrace works just fine for a normal user. You simply have access to fewer probes if you are less privileged.
Not the case on FreeBSD/Windows/macOS, where it's all or nothing. Still, on FreeBSD you just need root, on macOS you need to boot into a special kernel mode which doesn't even work on modern Apple Silicon machines.
Re:Oxide Computer releases distribution of illumos intended ...
by 4ad on Saturday February 03, 2024 @08:56AM
(#39240355)
DTrace in macOS was always a third class citizen, it never worked very well, and in fact, on arm64 machines it doesn't work at all (panics the kernel).
Re:Oxide Computer releases distribution of illumos intended ...
by sunshowers on Saturday February 03, 2024 @09:37PM
(#39247005)
That's really unfortunate :(
Re:Oxide Computer releases distribution of illumos intended ...
by roland-s on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @03:39AM
(#39201471)
Linux now has eBPF, which is essentially a VM running inside the Linux kernel. You can run your own programs on this little VM and extend the kernel to a staggering degree. Some clever folks have used this to build open source tracing tools that rival and even surpass Dtrace in some ways. Brendan Gregg, a Dtrace wizard and old colleague of some of the Oxide team back at Sun and Joyent, has some great resources on the subject
https://www.brendangregg.com/ebpf.html
https://www.brendangregg.com/blog/2018-10-08/dtrace-for-linu...
Bryan is just one out of several illumos experts here. If none of those were around, sure, maybe we wouldn't have picked illumos -- but then we'd be unrecognizably different.
I came into Oxide with a Linux background and zero knowledge of illumos. Learning about DTrace especially has been great.