I think that is fair. I was approaching this from the perspective of "my old machine was responsive, it is becoming less so." Back on the example of Doom, I understood why my machine at the time couldn't run Quake. It would be frustrating to force everyone to that paradigm.
(which CPU? render what? using how much of the available CPU power? with how many frames of latency allowed?)
Note that I don't fundamentally disagree with you and I cringe when I hear issues dismissed as "premature optimizations" myself.