Re:Why You've Never Been in a Plane Crash
by generic92034 on Monday January 29, 2024 @12:43PM
(#39179366)
If the maintenance of life boats is so dangerous and even costs more lives than it is expected to save, then in my eyes it would be the right reaction to invest into safety procedures for life boat maintenance, not getting rid of life boats.
Re:Why You've Never Been in a Plane Crash
by hef19898 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @03:06AM
(#39187521)
There are two things fundamentaly wrong with OPs comment:
1: That life boat maintenance is dangerous (anyway, for such a claim I'd expect numbers)
2: Directly comparing any death (!) happening during vessel maintennace and operation with lives saved during an vessel accident
Usually not worth further engaging with thisbkind of thinking online.
Titanic is the sweet spot for wanting more lifeboats, they had a long time, but they were in the middle of the ocean and nobody was coming to help.
If you go down very quickly lifeboats are useless. Herald of Free Enterprise could have had ten lifeboats per customer, wouldn't have made a difference, there were 90 seconds between nothing is wrong, and oops the ship is laying on its side in the water, lots of people are going to die in that scenario.
On the other hand if the port isn't far you can make for port. Despite a ship being on fire, or badly holed it may have hours left, the Titanic had almost three hours.