Re:Japan: Moon lander Slim comes back to life and resumes mi...
by soco on Monday January 29, 2024 @07:11AM
(#39175373)
As a rule of thumb, solutions starting with "just..." get something wrong.
Re:Japan: Moon lander Slim comes back to life and resumes mi...
by pvaldes on Monday January 29, 2024 @10:32AM
(#39177389)
As a rule of thumb, nobody sane would propose to go to the moon. I would be very disappointed if this people would follow general rules instead to point to the excelence.
Re:Japan: Moon lander Slim comes back to life and resumes mi...
by dotnet00 on Monday January 29, 2024 @07:56AM
(#39175689)
That's designing specifically for this failure case, when the typical case is that a sensor or engine encounters an overlooked edge case during the descent phase and smashes into the surface.
Re:Japan: Moon lander Slim comes back to life and resumes mi...
by pvaldes on Monday January 29, 2024 @10:24AM
(#39177288)
In such big projects as this, you just can't say "we didn't though about that, we will wait to see if we have luck".
Having B-plans for each specific case that you could reasonable obtain is a must. They were paid big sweet money for thinking about that.
The idea that the machine can be moved only if receives sun by some specific direction, is not logical when you play at this level.
Re:Japan: Moon lander Slim comes back to life and resumes mi...
by dotnet00 on Monday January 29, 2024 @11:36AM
(#39178346)
This isn't a $20B project paid for by a corrupt government and poorly educated population like what NASA deals with, where indeed they cannot go without a measure for every contingency and without promising to burn billions of dollars buying votes, because otherwise they won't get funding at all. This had a total cost of $121M.
Like any sane engineering project, it did accept some risk and chance of failure as part of the tradeoffs. Part of that was potentially landing in a bad orientation.
Re:Japan: Moon lander Slim comes back to life and resumes mi...
by pvaldes on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:07PM
(#39179801)
> not a project paid for by a corrupt government and poorly educated population like what NASA deals with,
Was that part really necessary?
If nose landing is ok for the Japanese, is ok for me.
Re:Japan: Moon lander Slim comes back to life and resumes mi...
by yencabulator on Monday January 29, 2024 @11:13AM
(#39177990)
Also, this failure case was loss of engine 50 meters high. That'll ruin the day of just about any landing strategy.
Just remove the up and down constrains and make any part able to be the upper part, or design it as a tumbler doll.