Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox
by jack-r-abbit on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @08:33PM
(#3917026)
sorry. no real desire to go further. I was simply pointing out that perhaps "antitrust" does mean what AJ007 thought it did. I believe there is a hint of that here. Probably not enough to make a legal case but enough to add another example to the "Some times Apple can be a real dick" list.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox
by tptacek on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @08:39PM
(#3917062)
Sure. If you wanted to take this further, a source linked from DOJ's website:
http://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/466/2/
Jefferson Parish Hosp. Dist. v. Hyde
(b) No tying arrangement can exist here unless there is a sufficient
demand for the purchase of anesthesiological services separate from
hospital services to identify a distinct product market in which it is
efficient to offer anesthesiological services separately from hospital
services. The fact that the exclusive contract requires purchase of
two services that would otherwise be purchased separately does not
make the contract illegal. Only if patients are forced to purchase the
contracting firm's services as a result of the hospital's market power
would the arrangement have anticompetitive consequences. If no forcing
is present, patients are free to enter a competing hospital and to use
another anesthesiologist instead of the firm.
Obviously, substitute "iPhone" for "Jefferson Parish Hospital", "iCoud" for bundled "anesthesiological services", and "Android" for "competing hospital" that customers are "free to enter".
Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox
by zaroth on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @10:47PM
(#3917414)
Here, let me help you with that ;-)
No tying arrangement can exist here unless there is a sufficient
demand for the purchase of cloud storage separate from a smartphone
OS to identify a distinct product market in which it is
efficient to offer cloud storage separately from the smartphone
OS. The fact that the exclusive contract requires purchase of
two services that would otherwise be purchased separately does not
make the contract illegal. Only if user are forced to purchase Apple's
services as a result of Apple's market power would the arrangement
have anticompetitive consequences. If no forcing is present, users
are free to purchase a competing smartphone and to use another
cloud storage provider instead of Apple.