News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox by dredmorbius on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @09:04PM (#3917138)
Anti-trust is based on behavior, not strictly market size.

If you're going to pull in market size, you've got to play to the relevant market as well.

One of the difficulties of anti-trust law is that it's fundamentally about power, which is not something economists have a particularly good measure for, nor are they particularly equipped to find (or be interested in finding) measurements for.

Even in a monopoly/monopsony or oligopoly/oligopsony cannot dictate both price and quantity (supply/demand curve), though in the traditional economic efficiency argument of the Chicago (free market) School, the concentration of buying/selling power means that (for sell-side concentration) prices are higher and quantities are lower, or (for buy-side concentration) prices are lower and quantities are higher, and more net value accrues to the side with greater concentration. The Chicago School cries tears over lost market efficiency.

But that's a far smaller problem than that monopoly allows the monopolist to choose winners. Maybe not for all time, but it's the same argument that's been used against command economies, bailouts, and even just plain government regulation. Generally wrongly in the last case, and mostly in the second.

Free markets are based on the principle that buyers, sellers, and ideas meet on equal footing. Where an entity or cabal can select winners, what you've got is no longer a free market.

Which is a pity, as free markets are generally powerful forces for good.

Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox by collision on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @08:19PM (#3916979)
Significant market share is enough for antitrust to be a concern. You don't need a monopoly, and indeed most companies engaging in anti-competitive behavior don't.
Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox by tptacek on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @08:24PM (#3916999)
An example of an antitrust case for someone with market share similar to Apple's in phones would be helpful. To head you off at one unproductive pass: it is unlawful to collude with other companies to fix prices even if you have a minority market share.
Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox by caf on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @08:36PM (#3917049)
Note though that it is an open question whether the relevant market is "phones" or "smartphones".
Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox by tptacek on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @08:36PM (#3917050)
That's true, but obviously Apple doesn't have a monopoly in either market (obviously, they are dwarfed by the total phone market).
Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox by taligent on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @08:35PM (#3917040)
Apple doesn't have anything close to a significant market share.

There is LOTS of competition in the market place.

Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox by khuey on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @08:40PM (#3917064)
Apple has significant market share. They just don't have anything close to a monopoly.
Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox by unreal37 on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @08:58PM (#3917119)
Apple has a near-monopoly in Tablets right? Doesn't have to be about phones.
Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox by cooldeal on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @08:35PM (#3917039)
So if Apple and Samsung independently do this, there can be norecourse since both of them aren't monopolies even if they have around 90% marketshare together. Even though the harmful effects on the market is the same.

I guess that explains why the US wireless and cable franchies suck and have the lowest consumer ratings.

Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox by tptacek on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @08:41PM (#3917073)
That's a weird example to use, since US cable franchises are in fact usually monopolies.
Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox by drzaiusapelord on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @08:56PM (#3917112)
Err, in the age of directv, dish network, dsl, vdsl, fiber, u-verse, 4g, etc I don't think ye olde cable monopoly is an excuse anymore.
Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox by Anechoic on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @09:14PM (#3917168)
dsl, vdsl, fiber, u-verse, 4g are extremely location dependent (I live in a top 100 MSA and don't have access to video over any of those modes at home), and even directv/dish have certain requirements (namely clear LOS to the satellite). For me it's Comcast or nothing, and I suspect that's the case (substituting "your local cableco" for "Comcast") for a majority of the USA.
Re:Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox by jerf on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @09:06PM (#3917146)
"So if Apple and Samsung independently do this, there can be norecourse since both of them aren't monopolies even if they have around 90% marketshare together. Even though the harmful effects on the market is the same."

No, abuse of oligarchies and cartels are illegal too.

It is generally understood that small numbers of entities can form oligarchies with no explicit coordination, so independence isn't necessarily a defense either.