News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by ijhuygft776 on Saturday January 27, 2024 @03:57PM (#39159758)
fetuses are not babies... and why would you want someone reminding you of a rape, daily?
Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by amatecha on Saturday January 27, 2024 @04:00PM (#39159781)
Not to mention, agency over one's corporeal self essentially dictates the right to abortion. I uncompromisingly assert the right to decide what happens to my body and decide what medical procedures to undergo.
Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by kingstoned on Saturday January 27, 2024 @04:02PM (#39159799)
Medical procedures such as vaccinations? Can people refuse any vaccinations in your view since it's their body?
Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by amatecha on Saturday January 27, 2024 @04:04PM (#39159824)
They sure can. It's their right[0]. It might be a bad choice, but it's theirs to make. There are enough sensible people to attain a good % of vaccination for whatever transmissible illness. We can avoid trampling on others' rights by ensuring a high standard of education -- the problem solves itself when people understand how/why things work the way they do.

[0] https://www.ohchr.org/en/human-rights/universal-declaration/... (article 3)

Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by jMyles on Saturday January 27, 2024 @04:17PM (#39159936)
...of... course. Particularly following the shoddy rollouts of the past few years, and the Gruber and Krause resignations, and the general limelight shown on VRBPAC and the FDA processes, it's pretty obvious that coercive uptake creates a set of horrible incentives. I'd think that's one of the lessons enjoying consensus henceforth.

Good vaccines are sufficiently awesome to drive adoption by dint of their effects. The most palpable effect of coercion is the presence of subpar vaccines on the market, tarnishing the reputation vaccination as a concept - which of course is dangerous for public health.

Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by orwin on Saturday January 27, 2024 @04:17PM (#39159934)
Yes! I think its fair though to have schools refusing to accept unvaccinated people if immunodeficient kids are present (and refuse non-vaccinated nurses in immunology and cancer wards), but absolutely, you should decide by yourself.
Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by jMyles on Saturday January 27, 2024 @04:19PM (#39159953)
Even those requirements need to be underpinned by clear evidence of a sterilizing effect of the vaccine in question.

(And I'm curious: by your logic, do you support re-adoption of the oral polio vaccine? Some interesting developments: https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/polio/who-prequalifies-next-gener...)

Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by HumblyTossed on Saturday January 27, 2024 @04:01PM (#39159787)
The cruelty is the point. The people making and passing these laws and people voting for the people to do it want this cruelty. They crave it.
Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by gremlinsinc on Saturday January 27, 2024 @05:08PM (#39160362)
They think, maybe rightfully so that this hurts the out group more than the in group (minorities), disclaimer: I'm a white male, except say that group is black or Hispanic, and have families that tend to vote the opposite way, then they're in effect hurting their own power hold by forcing more births.

They're so worried about immigrants taking jobs what about the anti abortion baby boom making jobs more scarce in 18 or 20 years, and changing whole political landscapes?

Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by throw0101d on Saturday January 27, 2024 @05:09PM (#39160374)
> fetuses are not babies...

This probably is the central question on this topic:

* When does the gamete/zygote/embryo/fetus/infant/whatever go from being not-human to being human?

Next:

* Just because it is/may be human, is it owed anything? [0]

Peter Singer for example has argued (in the past?) that even up to ~two years of age, the 'entity' should not be considered human:

> In Practical Ethics, Singer argues in favour of abortion rights on the grounds that fetuses are neither rational nor self-aware, and can therefore hold no preferences. As a result, he argues that the preference of a mother to have an abortion automatically takes precedence. In sum, Singer argues that a fetus lacks personhood.

> Similar to his argument for abortion rights, Singer argues that newborns lack the essential characteristics of personhood—"rationality, autonomy, and self-consciousness"[65]—and therefore "killing a newborn baby is never equivalent to killing a person, that is, a being who wants to go on living".[66]

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Singer#Euthanasia_and_in...

The various positions on the topic, if taken to their logical end, may lead to conclusions that folks may not realize if they haven't thought about it thoroughly:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_aspects_of_the_a...

[0] Thomson for one argued that we do not,[1] and even if you were (e.g.) in a cabin in the woods,[2] and one day there was a bay left on your front door, you could step over it and without any moral qualms

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Defense_of_Abortion

[2] > Some philosophers, like Thomson, think so, but very many philosophers disagree. If I live alone in the woods and wake one day to find an infant on my doorstep, am I obligated to care for it? Or may I simply step over it and go on about my day, until it dies from exposure and neglect? To think I am obligated in justice to help it, as a great many people (philosophers and non-philosophers alike) do, is to think we owe things to other people simply because they are people. And if we can owe things to other people simply because they are people, then Thomson’s argument falls apart. If the fetus becomes a person long before birth — as even Thomson concedes — and if we can owe things to people simply because they are people, then we can owe things to the fetus as well, long before birth. https://www.dallasnews.com/opinion/commentary/2022/06/05/phi...

[2] https://archive.is/y3DVM

Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by falcolas on Saturday January 27, 2024 @08:12PM (#39161546)
> * When does the gamete/zygote/embryo/fetus/infant/whatever go from being not-human to being human?

Per the US constitution, they are considered a person (an individual with human rights) after being born.

Per the Jewish faith (ditto Buddhist, Unitarian), upon their first breath.

Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by throw0101d on Saturday January 27, 2024 @10:08PM (#39162166)
> Per the US constitution, they are considered a person (an individual with human rights) after being born.

I'm not (that) familiar with the US constitution, so is there a specific reference?

Philosophizing here: One fetus could come come out at 8.5 months gestation and have rights, and another at 9.5 and gain rights. But the one that came out at 9.5 would have no rights at 8.5 because it just happens to still be in the uterus. What property of the fetus/whatever changes post-birth versus pre-birth that makes it have rights?

Another legal jurisdiction could have it defined in another fashion, so that would mean that they are both considered both a person and not a person, completely depending on an accidental characteristic (the location). Is there an 'objective' property to them/it that would lead to a classification regardless of location (uterus/not-uterus)?

Slightly sci-fi-y: what happens when artificial wombs are developed? I wonder what will being "born" be classified as in those (currently imaginary) situations.

Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by frompom on Monday January 29, 2024 @08:33AM (#39176022)
Ultimately we need to pick some point. Someone doesn't undergo some transformation upon becoming the age of a legal adult on midnight when becoming of age. Nor does age of consent suddenly confer reasoning capabilities that didn't exist the day prior. Legal definitions don't do well with nuance, we end up having to define thresholds that up close seem ridiculous. Whether it's a certain number of weeks, or upon birth, up close it would always look ridiculous like any other threshold.

In your example 8.5 months vs 9.5 months they may have actually have been conceived quite close to each other as well since gestation time is not actually based on date of conception but date of the last menstruation. So this, as well, is a relatively arbitrary measurement.

It's the reality of having to have universal absolute measures and terms in a world of edge cases and grey areas.

Being a thinking/aware person wouldn't happen suddenly, it would be gradual. Gradual rights would be damn near impossible to codify, so like everything else we have to pick some point that feels reasonable and yet will feel silly and arbitrary at the same time.

Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by zzo38computer on Saturday January 27, 2024 @05:48PM (#39160675)
> This probably is the central question on this topic: When does the gamete/zygote/embryo/fetus/infant/whatever go from being not-human to being human?

I disagree; that question is not relevant. Many people say it is relevant, but I disagree with that. Whether or not it is "human life" does not somehow mean it is better than everyone else.

What is relevant is: Conditions are not ideal, and if the child is a part of mother's body before they have been born then it is up to the mother to decide what to do with their body, to save themself, or if they prefer, to take a risk. Sometimes, the unborn child can be a danger to both themself and to their mother, although not always. It is best not to do abortion but conditions are not ideal so sometimes that might be better than the alternative. It is better to not even be pregnant at first if you do not want any children, if that is possible; but sometimes, unfortunately that does not work that way. So, sometimes the abortion will be a "necessary evil", possibly lesser than the other "evil" in some cases, because it is not as simple as they would have you to believe. You should perhaps consider something else first, but maybe you can't, for whatever reason; if you cannot, then abortion sooner rather than later will probably be better, for some reasons.

> If I live alone in the woods and wake one day to find an infant on my doorstep, am I obligated to care for it?

That is also not relevant for abortion, and they should not confuse it as such. If you are an orphanage then probably you should care for the child (if the orphanage is not completely full, I suppose), but otherwise you will have to decide yourself what (if anything) you will do (e.g. perhaps, you might try to figure out where the child came from and who put it there).

Wikipedia says, about "Judaism and abortion", that "The existing life takes precedence over the potential life." I have seen something similar before in a different context. I think that is reasonable. Whether or not it is "human life" is not the point (regardless of whether or not that is the point in the context it comes from; I am just taking that sentence for itself, in the general context of the discussion of abortion). That does not mean that potential life is worthless. It should mean, that sometimes is necessary to consider the risk and how to consider such a risk in such a case, because the existing life is considered "better" for this purpose, if necessary.

However, the above is only about if abortion should be moral; none of that is the same as considering whether or not abortion should be legal. I think that, being illegal causes more problems, and that it should be legal, even if not encouraged. (Unfortunately, sometimes making something legal will cause people to encourage it, so that is a possible argument against it.) The law could not consider the circumstances properly; people can consider their own body by themself, and any doctors they wish to consult; not the difficulty of dealing with government, police, etc. However, nobody should be allowed to give an abortion to someone who does not wish it.

(Making exceptions for rape, etc isn't the solution either, since then they would have to know if it is rape, which just adds delays and other legal issues.)

Apparently in some jurisdictions there is "double homicide" if you kill someone who is pregnant, even if abortion is legal. I think it makes sense, at least in some cases, such as if they were deliberately trying to kill the child (for their inheritance or for whatever other reason they may have had a motive to do so).

Rather, the laws should be made to reduce needing abortion; that will reduce abortion, because even if something is illegal, the people will do it anyways (possibly less than if it is legal, but still it will be done anyways).

Re:Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states by throw0101d on Saturday January 27, 2024 @10:18PM (#39162220)
> I disagree; that question is not relevant. Many people say it is relevant, but I disagree with that. Whether or not it is "human life" does not somehow mean it is better than everyone else.

I do not think there is (necessarily) any claim that if it is a human life/person it is "better", but rather 'just' equal to any other human life (including the mother's).

Generally the only two situations that most (Western?) societies have allowed the taking of life is self-defence and capital punishment (which can sometimes be treated as 'societal self-defence' if (e.g.) prison infrastructure cannot keep dangerous offenders locked up safely: the only way to prevent them from further harming people in society is to remove the threat).

If a life (mother's) is in danger, than one can claim an action is self-defence in order to save it. But if there is no threat to a life, what right is there to take another's? What has the fetus done to 'deserve' death in the latter case?

> (Making exceptions for rape, etc isn't the solution either, since then they would have to know if it is rape, which just adds delays and other legal issues.)

Even if it is rape, if the Entity involved is a human person, what has it done to deserve to die?