Re:Skype replaces P2P supernodes with Linux boxes hosted by ...
by Wilya on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @03:11PM
(#3915930)
Is MSN P2P ? It's been a long time (like.. oh. 7 years maybe ?) since I've used it, but iirc it was centrally routed. Only some things like file transfers were P2P.
Re:Skype replaces P2P supernodes with Linux boxes hosted by ...
by wetsocket on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @05:45PM
(#3916521)
MSN relies on central servers to broker connections, just like this does. It is not going to solve the problem you describe.
True P2P, via an overlay, where you and the other person(s) have a direct connection, is fast and reliable "enough" (otherwise Skype would not have been successful), but not perfect. Nor is store-and-forward (e.g. text mesaging) perfect either. But it is "good enough" for people to use it.
If I were really concerned about "lost messages", I'd prefer a direct connection as opposed to one that goes through a third party. It just makes more sense.
Re:Skype replaces P2P supernodes with Linux boxes hosted by ...
by riffraff on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @03:52PM
(#3916101)
from what we get from the article: no, they are replacing the bit about connecting over NAT, which went through some random people, making it go through some servers they own directly.
If you and your peer are on mutually accessible networks the data will still be p2p in the same way (or not, as before).
Re:Skype replaces P2P supernodes with Linux boxes hosted by ...
by grandpoobah on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @08:09PM
(#3916943)
I have a fair amount of experience with MSNP, and it is the exact opposite of P2P. Some things like file transfers will sometimes use P2P if it's available.
So in theory this will prevent any messages ever getting lost en route to the recipient?
I can't tell you how many messages have gone undelivered between my friends and I when we used to use MSN messenger exclusively (even happens once or twice on Skype), causing serious breakdowns in communication. ("Did you get that message? Did you get that message?)
I always wished they'd switch to this architecture.