News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Untranslatable by stcredzero on Friday January 26, 2024 @02:45PM (#39147187)
Except, a French speaker could well just reply, "Donc" without anything else in contexts where an English speaker would never say, "Therefore."

In those contexts, "Donc" is more like, "Word!" or "Right on." I would translate those to mean, "Agreed."

Or is that just French that French teachers and textbooks talk about to students in America?

Re:Untranslatable by atnnn on Friday January 26, 2024 @03:32PM (#39147878)
I would say "donc" is used where some might say "so" in English (aka shorter and less pompous "therefore").

I think the meaning of "Agreed" or "Right on" is rare and more implicit. Like saying "therefore" might mean "I accept the premise".

As a question, "donc?", like "so?", can mean "and then?", "then what?", "meaning what?", "what next?" or "so what?"

As an interjection or at the beginning of a sentence, "donc", like "so", can mean "now then", "that said", "moving on" or "without further ado".

Re:Untranslatable by stcredzero on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:25PM (#39149562)
Like saying "therefore" might mean "I accept the premise".

I basically never hear that as a standalone reply in English!

As an interjection or at the beginning of a sentence, "donc", like "so", can mean "now then", "that said", "moving on" or "without further ado".

I'm not sure, but I think sometimes when my wife is saying, "schma" it's somewhat like "donc" you describe above. But sometimes, I think she expressing agreement with a person that a third party was a bit mistaken or off the mark, so it's expressing a kind of disagreement. Not sure.