Coming back to D&D as an adult (coworkers play during lunch once a week) has been strange. The new style of play feels rigid. I can understand the standardization to try and create a uniform experience but it feels like a little of that AD&D magic is lost. Also I’m an adult now haha
I've been realizing more and more how true this was.
I haven't played either D&D or AD&D since the early 90s. At the time the people I played with would laugh at how encyclopedic I was about the rules, source material, etc. But these days I'll go to r/adnd or something like that and see someone talking about a thing from 1ed AD&D and my reaction is "WTF? I had no idea that existed!".
Or people talking about how of course every group played a certain way, and I never played that way in any group.
Which now leaves me always astounded at how much stuff I had no idea existed. To your age point, that was definitely a part of it. I played from about age 8 to late teens. In retrospect, a lot of this stuff was over my head
One rule set is Dungeon Crawl Classics - https://necroticgnome.com/products/old-school-essentials-adv...
Not a lot. (though Old School Essentials is based on the earlier Basic/Expert or B/X rules, not BECMI [0]) Generally the biggest change is that almost all OSR games use ascending armor class.
> What would motivate a group to pick up one of these, rather than say a reprint of the Rules Cyclopedia (or using a free digital copy from archive.org)?
Old School Essentials is far more clearly written and easier to use. A lot of thought was put into layout so that all of the relevant rules for a given topic (e.g. the steps involved in character creation, or the dungeon exploration rules) fit on a single two-page spread. Spell descriptions are bullet-pointed in a way that makes it very easy to check their effects at a glance.
You can check out the free version and see for yourself [1].
Edit: Another thing to keep in mind is that when the OSR first started you couldn't get print-on-demand versions of old rule books from Wizards. If you wanted to play with something like BECMI you had to hunt for the box sets or the Rules Cyclopedia on eBay or in Half-Price Books, or get pirated PDFs. OSR games provided an alternative.
[0]: https://www.reddit.com/r/osr/comments/evax7d/bx_vs_becmi/
[1]: https://necroticgnome.com/products/old-school-essentials-bas...
Kinda weird to differentiate between B/X and BECMI, considering Companion/Master/Immortals are extensions for higher level characters using the same Basic/Expert rules.
Edit: the distinction still seems pedantic to me, but these helped to understand the differences in the context of OSR:
https://leyline.press/blogs/leyline-press-blog/a-comparative...
https://leyline.press/blogs/leyline-press-blog/a-comparative...
tl;dr: old school versions apply clarifications and enhancements to the original B/X rules for smoother gameplay, some add additional content, and many people want to avoid paying anything to WotC
When my sons were 6 I decided to introduce them to the game. The 5e Starter Set had just come out and it was so similar to the original Basic Box of my youth. The rules were very different and often not in a good way: it was too sterile and formal, not as shaggy and weird as AD&D. But it was fun, and they loved it. I imagine there will be a time, 40 years from now, when they teach it to their sons.