Of course, the exact same warnings apply to every single app anyone has ever downloaded off the internet, so I can't really agree with AIR's stance except in the purest abstract.
Just this week, the Paint.NET folks were blogging about not being able to move to the latest version of Windows Installer because XP installs without SP3 won't have the runtime by default. For a downloadable application, extra megabytes are a big blow and extra required steps from the user are an absolute killer. Why would you take the upfront hit to people trying your software?
Java and .NET are still far less prevalent in the apps-for-sale market than they are in the inhouse-corporate market, and I think this is largely the reason why.
The sandbox security restrictions are HUGE as it is and add days of programing time already, why halve our install base with scare tactics?
If you can get past the AIR app install, it automatically launches it for you.
I don't know which would be easier for grandma to do.
Comepare this to AIR: •flash is required •specific flash version required •install air runtime •install air app •present REALLY scary warning to user (causes massive dropoffs in the installation process) •require 200-400$ cert from dev to make that warning 5% less scary.