Why do we have to be hackers? What was wrong with being developers?
Hackers became criminals and developers were Javabean coding wage slaves... given a choice criminal sounds cooler then wage slave.
But the article (and my anecdotal experiences) are proof that this hasn't actually happened. We decided to call ourselves 'hackers', but society as a whole doesn't.
given a choice criminal sounds cooler then wage slave.
I think that's my main problem with "hacker". It's an attempt to be cool.
It's a good thing journalists generally do no have Milner's level of knowledge, as surely they too would abuse it. Maybe even worse than Google. Milner's comment reflects the power of the knowledge he has. He has to take some responsibility for it.
Both Google engineers and NYT journalists do snooping on others for a living.
They are just at odds with each other, for various reasons; engineers for companies like Google generally do not like journalists and generally the same is true vice versa.
Google has a genuine PR problem. And journalists are watching their careers disintegrate with the advance of communications technology. It's an amusing little spat to watch.
Looking past the scare quotes, according to the FCC report it was just Kismet, and the problem basically just came down to deciding to write the non encrypted payloads to disk. He might know too much about wifi, but probably half the regular HN posters could have implemented the same system, if they chose to.
Precisely.
I know Kismet exists. I know I can install and run it. I know I can even break wi-fi encryption in some cases. But that doesn't mean I'm going to do this, for commercial purposes, for a company like Google.
Engaging in questionable behavior which others with similar skills forgo is what distinguishes black hat from white hat hacking.
I am more than moderately offended/troubled/irked by this excerpt, as it appears to deliberately depict the engineer as a "hacker" in the sense of Hollywood culture, rather than "hacker" as we know it in makers' terms.
In the wrong hands, the English language is much more potent and destructive than any programming language. An English Specialist can often cause more harm than a Wi-Fi Specialist.