Re:Getting Beaten By A Voting Bot In 50 Minutes
by ericd on Monday April 30, 2012 @08:00PM
(#3912232)
Yeah, that's possible too. I ruled that out because they weren't going to announce for 5 days, so they'd have time to analyze/tweak the data after the voting was finished, rather than messing with the live data. Their tweak just removed a bit of data from the page, doubtful it was significantly different logic-wise. Even if Zillow and PadMapper were doing nefarious things, it's unlikely that they would have the same proportion of fraudulent votes while AL had far less, though - that would require coordination between PM and Zillow or some outside factor that would cause us to naturally cheat the same amount.
Re:Getting Beaten By A Voting Bot In 50 Minutes
by andrewfelix on Monday April 30, 2012 @08:24PM
(#3912321)
>started removing what they considered to be fraudulent votes during the blackout period
I doubt they'd begin this process while voting was still taking place.
Here's an alternate explanation to the events observed: The Webby admins started removing what they considered to be fraudulent votes during the blackout period. Most of these removed votes came from PadMapper and Zillow, which increased (linearly) Apartment List's percentage.
Full disclosure: I have no dog in this fight. I haven't used any of the services mentioned, and I've only really heard of Zillow.