News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by D13Fd on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:43AM (#39118665)
I don't think that's the problem. The problem is "publish or perish" and the fact that survival and job advancement depend on quantity over quality of publications. That drives a huge demand to be published, and the purpose of getting published is not to advance science but to get more bullet points on an a C.V.
Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by beezlebroxxxxxx on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:53AM (#39118801)
I agree. One thing that is pretty depressing to anyone that spends time in grad school or in academia is that universities and colleges put barely any importance on a professor/scholar's teaching ability. Education is simply not the main focus at all. Instead, they view scholars as research machines. Rather than giving research and scholarly inquiry the time and patience it requires (a lot), they would have published research occur like clockwork and in many cases regardless of the quality of that published research. This looks better for the school; but leads to middling research at best and often shady stuff by harried researchers, and a subpar teaching experience for most students who are always second fiddle to the endless demands to publish. The school benefits (per se, they don't like getting caught in scandals of their own making, of course), while researchers and students get subpar experiences all around.
Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by life-and-quiet on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:13PM (#39120663)
Exactly why I left academia with my Master's and didn't pursue a PhD. A few years into my professional life I met a PhD who had actually gotten tenure and gave it up to come work in industry. When I asked him whether he missed academia he said, "I miss the idea of it, but the idea isn't what it is."
Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by bee_rider on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:51AM (#39118778)
The fact that we pull metrics (for hiring) from the scientific record causes the publish-or-perish problem, so I’m not sure I see a disagreement here.
Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by chengiz on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:42PM (#39121052)
You are reversing cause and effect. You "perish" by being unable to procure grants. Grants require a publishing record. Why? Because estimating success is harder than simply looking up a list. The entire system works that way. The hiring procedures are simply following this system.
Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by searine on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:07AM (#39119008)
>"publish or perish" and the fact that survival and job advancement depend on quantity over quality of publications.

I mean, kind of but not really.

Any academic of even marginal skill can smell a padded CV from a mile away. The type that do this are not serious people and will waste your time and resources. Knowing how to identify an imposter is a survival trait.

Usually the type to pad a CV with garbage are eyeing admin or corporate gigs, not academic success. A search committee or tenure committee wouldn't look too kindly at a bunch of wacky papers in the east austrian journal of ass-scratch.

Yes there is huge demand to be published, but quality matters a lot if you intend to seriously participate in the scientific community.

Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by pvaldes on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:25AM (#39119217)
> Any academic of even marginal skill can smell a padded CV from a mile away

A couple drops of "Eau de Népotisme" and the smell goes away miraculously. Torturing your job requisites so only the desired local candidate can apply is a way to "solve" it.

Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by cycomanic on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:20PM (#39120747)
In my experience this happens very rarely. In most places that I'm aware of, there is a very strong aversion to hiring local candidates for tenured (or tenure track) positions.

For example, in Germany it is extremely rare to become a professor at the. University where you did your phd/postdoc. It's almost always seen a something not quite right.

Now there is still lots of politics involved in the hiring process. Tenured positions are rare and often the other academics on the committee want to candidates which strengthen their own research area (although interestingly if there is a colleague down the corridor or someone at a university half way around the world who can do some technique you require, collaboration is much more likely to happen with the external person)

Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by pvaldes on Saturday January 27, 2024 @04:52AM (#39154147)
Is inversely proportional to the scarcity of the resources available