Re:Unbloating the Buffers
by Animats on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @12:25AM
(#39113943)
> The biggest problem with CAKE/CoDel is that if you're not deploying it on the bottleneck device.
Right. This is a scheme for trying to manage the flows from the end you control so that the clueless FIFO nodes out there don't overload.
Flow management should be at the point where multiple flows feed into a bottleneck. Usually at the point where the LAN connects to the outside world, the telco modem or cable box. And, in the other direction, where bulk bandwidth goes into limited bandwidth to the consumer at the upstream end. I'm encouraged to hear that this finally got into DOCSIS. Now if only we could get it into AT&T modems.
Right. This is a scheme for trying to manage the flows from the end you control so that the clueless FIFO nodes out there don't overload.
Flow management should be at the point where multiple flows feed into a bottleneck. Usually at the point where the LAN connects to the outside world, the telco modem or cable box. And, in the other direction, where bulk bandwidth goes into limited bandwidth to the consumer at the upstream end. I'm encouraged to hear that this finally got into DOCSIS. Now if only we could get it into AT&T modems.