If their argument boils down to "well, they should have agreed to make their system just as shitty as the rest of our systems so that they could be crappily compatible" then it's not hard to see why Google went a different direction.
Google's defense is incredibly weak. relying mostly on fair use.
the fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any other means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright.
Since that order emphasizes the importance of the APIs, it probably weighs in Oracle's favor.
We'll find out for sure in a few days.
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2012/04/oracle-presi...
> There is one thing the jury won't know: the issue of whether APIs can be copyrighted at all is actually up in the air. It's a legal gray area that will be decided by Judge William Alsup—but only after the jury gives its verdict in this case. (When that happens, even a jury verdict in Oracle's favor could be a hollow one.)
which is exactly what felipeko was referring to.
If a juror genuinely believes that the idea of copyrighting APIs and extending that copyright to alternate implementations makes no sense, how can they come up with a decision that's anything but arbitrary? That's like me saying, 'Assume that 1 * 5 = 0, and then decide if if the satisfiability problem can be solved in linear time'.
If you give me a nonsensical set of assumptions, how can I come up with an answer that's not also nonsensical? If you give me some messed up numerical system like that one, well sure, maybe those definitions would propagate though to the definition of polynomial complexity as well. But what does that mean for the real world? Nothing - and law is meant to be applied, not some abstract theoretical exercise.
I just posted this to highlight the fact that things are in Oracle's favor.
jury told by Judge to assume APIs are copyrightable.
Since that order emphasizes the importance of the APIs, it probably weighs in Oracle's favor.
I mean, look at it this way - GNU is almost completely compatible with Unix, but it was rebuilt from the ground up. Even if AT&T hadn't given out the license for free, you'd have a hard time convincing me that GNU breaks some sort of copyright - the entire damn codebase was rewritten from the ground up. The design of the operating system may be the same, but copyrighting that is as ridiculous as patenting a geometric shape.
There's a time to everything, a time to tear down and a time to build - Ecclesiastes.
Having said that, you are quite right to credit Romain for a lot of the UI we see in Android, and there's also a reason why he didn't stay at Sun: he was one of the few graphic engineers who actually cared about releasing good graphical user interfaces.
Failure of J2ME had to do with the flawed process, the technology, the design, the backwardness, the inability to keep up with times, the failure of the WORA promise, the fragmentation and Sun's management lacking any and all vision. Licensing from Sun would have likely meant Google would have found itself in a déjà vu situation. That was the point I was trying to make :)
(also, Android has a compatibility test system/process)
Desktop: true.
Mobile: wasn't Java ME on a bazillion feature phones?
Java is also installed on a bazillion desktops, numbers don't change the fact that the ui framework is very bad.
Historically applets lost to flash for that same reason
Yep, because there wasn't anything else. But it was painful, slow in terms of progress and incomplete (JSR297 - they are still working on 3D graphics API standardization). And hey no one liked it and knew it far as I can tell - talk real fragmentation.
The world wouldn't look very different today if those phones had run a completely different stack. Or even if it wasn't possible to write apps for them at all.
Google nicked the programming language off Sun and an interface off Apple.
Besides, writing J2ME swing style apps was what made a developer puke although the end result of it, the UI was also painful to look at if not as much.
If you were to take a good, portable language which a ton of developers are already familiar with and make it successful on the mobile - you are not going to go with Sun, JCP or any other "community" designed models.
So Google's problem was that they liked the Java language and they had to attract developers so they had to adopt the API but they had to throw away the rest of Java - including the JVM, Swing and ton of other useless-for-mobile APIs none of which were really a viable option on mobile.
So you could argue that Google could have been a good citizen, good Sun friend etc. but if they had to take J2ME and/or JCP for that, it would clearly defeat the purpose of Google entering the mobile market.
And I don't understand what McNealy's quote about "they [Google] don't share" is all about - it's open source, Oracle can adopt Android UI APIs or whatever else they wanted. If this is about money - yeah may be Google should have thrown them some bucks but I guess it had to be done under "licensing" which again would have meant dealing with Sun's "Community Process", "Standardization" and other bloat all of which were directly responsible for J2ME not going anywhere in the first place.
Another issue is that Gosling seems to be FUD mongering with Compatibility stick - "we've got organizations of people that do compatibility testing and actual negotiating amongst the different handset makers so that things like GPS APIs look the same." Android has standardized GPS API since I don't know when and that doesn't seem to have been a problem with any of the dozen Android devices I've used. The only difference is Google puts out those APIs and it works with manufacturers to amend / add as required. Google has the final say over APIs which is a good thing - you don't want hardware vendors designing software APIs that work cross device - that is best left to people who know that sort of thing. And not having a sanctioned committee with varying interests wrangling each other and slowing down progress has also worked out well for Google and Android.