News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OO JS in 15mins or Less by jseims on Monday April 30, 2012 @01:04PM (#3910121)
An OO JS tutorial should also include a discussion of the this pointer, and how it's not like other OO languages.

In JS, this reflects the context of the caller, not the object (which I think is messed up), so you have to learn call and apply.

Re:OO JS in 15mins or Less by mdgrech23 on Monday April 30, 2012 @01:16PM (#3910206)
My first thought here was holy cow yes it should! My second though was ack, there's a lot to go over. Sounds like a good topic to cover in a second post. However if you see a way to nicely integrate into the current post in brevity I'm all ears and would be happy to update the post :) Thanks!
Re:OO JS in 15mins or Less by tikhonj on Monday April 30, 2012 @08:22PM (#3912310)
The problem is that in JavaScript functions (and, consequently, methods) are first-class citizens. If `this` reflected the value of the object, certain code would work oddly:

    var a = {fn : function () {this.doStuff()}},
        b = {};
    b.method = a.fn;// What now?
So what JavaScript did actually makes some sense.

Another viable solution would be to have `this` passed into a method explicitly, like in Python. Then the expression `a.b()` could desugar to something like `a.b(a)` with `b` expecting `this` as its first argument. This also has some disadvantages. You could also do like Lua and have a separate syntax for calling methods this way (a:b()), but this is also confusing.

In short, there is no perfect solution.