News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by Animats on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:21AM (#39100498)
It's an ekranoplan. The USSR made several. The actual vehicle is from a company called Regent.[1] They do have a quarter-scale prototype, and a video. This web site is from some group trying to get funding for a service.

The current Regent ekranoplan, not yet shipping, is a 12 passenger model. That seems small for an inter-island ferry. It would be faster than a ferry, but since the existing inter-island ferry routes only run about an hour, more speed may not be worth the trouble.

Probably just a tourist attraction.

[1] https://archive.is/CkcJI

Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by noduerme on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:44AM (#39100605)
I'm not sure where you're getting this. There are no inter-island ferries anymore in Hawaii, except for the short tourist hops from Maui to Lanai and Molokai. Much longer trips between the big island, Maui and Oahu were possible for a couple years up until 2009 on the Superferry, but it closed after years of legal wrangling over environmental issues.
Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by pinot on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:49AM (#39100632)
Big Island never got superferry. Back in the 70s there was Seaflite on Boeing hydroplanes that was short lived as well.
Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by johnwalkr on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @11:09AM (#39105239)
Not sure why the Boeing 929 was a failure in so many places, but you can still ride them in Japan and Hong Kong. The experience is fun --they are fast, security is light and the vessels are retro-futuristic. I rode one from Tokyo to Izu-Oshima and it was 1:45 vs 6:00 for the normal ferry.
Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by noduerme on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:13AM (#39114207)
Thanks for the correction.
Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by bruce511 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:47AM (#39100616)
>> Probably just a tourist attraction.

Yes and no. One the one hand, absolutely a tourist attraction. Its projected to be cheaper than flying, and hopes to be a lot less hassle. (Expect pushback from the airlines. )

However small capacity, cheap, accessible transport is a boon for islanders living in archipelago. For starters you're not bound to islands big enough for an airport.

Given that the vehicle is electric, and hawaii has abundant solar energy, it could end up being very cost effective.

So what starts small, and touristy, might end up being mainstream and useful in lots of similar (ie island) contexts.

On the environmental front I expect the usual "complain about anything new" crowd, coupled with push-back from existing operators. But it's hard to see how this does more environmental harm than planes or boats.

Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by eesmith on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @03:52AM (#39101020)
> for starters you're not bound to islands big enough for an airport.

The competition for that space is seaplanes, including both floatplanes and flying boats, which have been around for a century. Electric versions of those exist, like https://harbourair.com/corporate-responsibility/goingelectri... , and https://el-fly.no/ wants to build an electric amphibious flying boat.

Yes, a ground-effect vehicle has better wing efficiency than an aircraft. However, it has disadvantages, like how it handles waves. A flying boat, for example, only needs to worry about the waves at the departure and arrival locations, which may be in a protected harbor or channel, while a GEV must deal with larger waves between the islands.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ground-effect_vehicle#Advantag... for additional comparisons.

> So what starts small, and touristy

I flew on a seaplane between the US and the Bahamas, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chalk%27s_International_Airlin... . It was a fun touristy thing, but not touristy enough to maintain a commercial seaplane service.

> On the environmental front I expect the usual "complain about anything new" crowd

Thing is, this isn't new. Ground effect vehicles have been around for decades, the technology is pretty mature, and the problems also pretty well known. If someone cracks that nut - great! - but a lot of people have tried and failed to extend its use outside of some niche areas. That history of failure tends to dampen enthusiasm.

> But it's hard to see how this does more environmental harm than planes or boats.

That calculation is not easy. If you want to minimize environmental harm the most, switch to sailboat. Cook used no fossil fuels to travel to and around Hawaii, and neither did the Polynesians who discovered the place.

If you want to minimize CO2 emissions, ban all inter-island flights and switch to ferries - https://ourworldindata.org/travel-carbon-footprint says ferries emit about 1/7th of the CO2 as short-haul flights.

And there are electric ferries these days, like https://www.electrive.com/2021/03/02/worlds-largest-electric... , though that's not ocean going. See https://electrek.co/2023/01/17/worlds-largest-electric-ferry... for one in the works.

Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by bruce511 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:08PM (#39108061)
>> The competition for that space is seaplanes, including both floatplanes and flying boats

Airplanes operate in a hostel environment where the penalty for failure is severe. The translates into a lot of (good) regulation which makes planes expensive to make, and expensive to maintain.

Ground effect vehicles are more in the car/boat space when it comes to mechanical failure. Sure I'm not saying it can be made of some wire and duct tape, but the necessary mechanical standard is a -lot- lower (ie cheaper.)

>> . If you want to minimize environmental harm

Sure. Or stay home. There's always something better. But that wasn't the hypothesis. The statement was that its better than planes or (motor) boats.

Frankly, if an electric craft is charged from solar or wind, its already as good as a sailboat.

Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by Animats on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:15PM (#39109949)
> Ground effect vehicles are more in the car/boat space when it comes to mechanical failure.

Not quite. This thing depends on dynamic stability. If a wingtip touches the water at speed, it will probably flip. It has to turn without banking. So it has many of the stability and control problems of an aircraft at landing, plus some of the wave problems of a seaplane. It's not like a big, wide hovercraft, where, if you lose power, you just settle down into boat mode.

Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by eesmith on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @03:49PM (#39109575)
> which makes planes expensive to make, and expensive to maintain

Understood. Though as the comparison link mentions, there's another important cost - "limited utility has kept production levels low enough that it has been impossible to amortize development costs sufficiently to make GEVs competitive with conventional aircraft".

I don't pretend to have more than a surface knowledge about topic, but when the idea has been around decades, developed and promoted for decades, and is still only a niche mode of travel (along with hovercraft, hydrofoil, and flying boats), that tells me the doubts aren't simply from those who "complain about anything new".

> The statement was that its better than planes or (motor) boats.

Sure. My comment was to point out how complicated the full calculation was, because it should include the electric ferries that becoming available, and not limit itself to motor boats.

Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by Jemm on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:20AM (#39116945)
> I flew on a seaplane between the US and the Bahamas, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chalk%27s_International_Airlin... . It was a fun touristy thing, but not touristy enough to maintain a commercial seaplane service.

Chalks suffered a tragic structural failure, likely caused by corrosion, which mostly ended the company.

Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by brigade on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:29AM (#39101295)
The airlines are the ones already investing and planning on operating these, first as an alternative to their Cessnas and other <30 seat commuter planes. The real question is whether these actually materialize or if Regent goes the way of basically every previous aviation startup.

Certainly claiming these could be in service next year is a tad over optimistic.

Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by Simon_ORourke on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:34AM (#39100566)
The Ekranoplan, or so-called Caspian Sea Monster, was truly massive, and could no doubt fit several of these puny tourist versions in its hold. For these kind of endeavours you'd really want to go big or home - there's a limited enough tourist market if all you're planning to transport is some sightseers without any luggage!

Something that could take a few shipping containers, automobiles, passengers etc. however, you'd think there would be a greater demand for something like that.

Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:48AM (#39100625)
> The Ekranoplan, or so-called Caspian Sea Monster, was truly massive,

Ekranoplan is a class of vehicles; the "Caspian Sea Monster" was an individual experimental ekranoplan (the Lun-class was a later large combat ekranoplan, with a short career.)

> For these kind of endeavours you'd really want to go big or home

I don't know, I think for commercial ventures without bottomless military funding backing, starting small makes sense, there's lots of places small tourist ekranoplans could find a market.

Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by bink on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:43AM (#39100596)
Which inter-island ferry are you referring to? Hawaii doesn't have them.
Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by XEKEP on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:51AM (#39100640)
see Maui to Lanai ferry https://go-lanai.com/
Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by bink on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:29PM (#39108421)
Interesting. That's only the very short trip between Maui and Lanai though. Still an improvement over the zero ferries that existed back when I lived there.
Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by jessriedel on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:55AM (#39100659)
> It's an ekranoplan. The USSR made several.

No, this is a combination ekranoplan and hydrofoil. I think whether it's classified as the "world's first" is going to depend on what counts as operational, but it's certainly much less common than ekranoplans.

Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by magicalhippo on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @07:22AM (#39102425)
As an aside, rctestflight over on YouTube has made a number of attempts[1] at making a good RC ground-effect vehicle. Due to physics this is a lot harder for smaller vehicles.

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3heh9swH2Zw&list=PLXvxJNOIXB...

Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by wkat4242 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @09:05AM (#39103417)
The USSR one in your link isn't even the craziest ekranoplan :) This one was huge and used 8 jet engines: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lun-class_ekranoplan . It looks to me like a failed Kerbal Space Program experiment (moah engines!) but curiously enough it was in actual operational service.

The one in the link actually looks fairly sane, it's smaller and powered by only 1 turboprop by the looks of it (edit: nope it has 2 turbofans in the nose too). https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/A-90_Orlyonok

Edit: oops I see it was already mentioned sorry. I was reading on mobile.

Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by happyopossum on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @10:09AM (#39104301)
> but since the existing inter-island ferry routes only run about an hour, more speed may not be worth the trouble

What inter-island ferry routes? There aren’t any, and when there were many of the routes were muuuuuch longer than an hour. The I harbored portion of the island chain is almost 300 miles long - a trip from Hilo to Honolulu would be ~240 miles.

Re:The Hawai'I Seaglider Initiative – A New Approach to Trav... by chipsa on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @11:41AM (#39105753)
The small size is actually the point? One of the big problems with the Superferry was the places the ferry went, didn't want to have a bunch of people showing up at once cheaply for... NIMBY reasons.