Older cars were.
Manufacturers never designed their own brake pads, they picked a caliper design that closely fit an existing wheel.
Carburetors? Just fit one from a carburetor manufacturer (weber, etc).
Steering racks, balljoints ... many fit multiple brands.
Alternators, radiators, various water tanks ... all from a common parts manufacturer, then used in several brands. Thermostats used to be a common design too.
Hell, they don't even do their own transmissions - just get a ZF-whatever.
When Hyundai launched their gen-1 Elantra ~1990, it came with a Mitsubishi engine.
Wheel bearings, CV joints - one design fit many different brands.
The repairability of older cars was amazing in retrospect.
Today it's different - you are unlikely to find brake pads from a Ford that fits a Toyota.
The companies spent extra money on design, to make that internal part significantly different, then extra money on tooling to actually build it, just so that you cannot buy a replacement unless its from them.
That said, many components of newer cars are still largely supplied by the same companies across brands.
Why is that?
> The companies spent extra money on design, to make that internal part significantly different, then extra money on tooling to actually build it, just so that you cannot buy a replacement unless its from them.
Note that none of those were branded as Toyota/Lexus original parts, nor sold by them. If they did all that design work in order to capture spare parts sales, they forgot to do the second part of that strategy.
My point isn't that aftermarket manufacturers stepped in, my point is that, with old cars, the design was close to, if not identical to, an existing caliper, even if that was from a different manufacturer.
Maybe it was because many manufacturers didn't design or manufacture their own calipers - it was done by bendix, et al. Now they spend extra money designing their own, often with no obvious benefit.
> Note that none of those were branded as Toyota/Lexus original parts, nor sold by them. If they did all that design work in order to capture spare parts sales, they forgot to do the second part of that strategy.
That's only the brake pads bit. I mentioned quite a few other components, too.
Steering tie rod ends (the part that tends to wear), balljoints, radiators*, coolant expansion tank*, washer fluid reservoir*, thermostats, Wheel bearings, CV joints (sold as full axles)
https://www.rockauto.com/en/catalog/toyota,2020,camry,2.5l+l...
* Part not from RockAuto, but available from several other aftermarket suppliers
I couldn't find an alternator for the hybrid, but I'm not sure if it has one, or if charging is part of the HSD. It's available for the non-hybrid, of course.
I turn all the wrenches on our family cars. It's extremely rare that I have to go to a dealer for a part. Like once a decade rare.
My point is not that aftermarket parts are made to match the original, it's that in older cars the original itself was made to match something that existed.
The fact that you can get Mazda brake pads from Bendix is completely irrelevant to the fact that you now can't get Mazda brake pads from a Ford parts bin, whilst on older cars you could!
I couldn't quickly find other examples of Mazda/Ford crossover brake pads other than the badge-engineered vehicles.
Conspiracy theories aside, the reason is more likely that by designing the part themselves, for a common set of applications at that manufacturer the cost is far lower than designing the rest of the car around the part.
IOW: I have 1 cubic foot available for an assembly. I can custom design an assembly for the best performance I can get in that space, or I can redesign the engine compartment to get more than 1 ft^3 of space to fit the off the shelf part into.
One could argue that Lamborghini could just drop a Ford Triton V10 into the Huracan and call it a day (it would save tens of thousands of dollars per car), but would that allow the rest of the car to still look like it does? Perform like it does?
Enshrining right-to-repair into law is, in my opinion, a pretty good way to make sure that field-repairability is factored into the design. But I don't think its productive to force manufacturers to use a particular design technique to achieve that requirement. That hobbles their ability to actually deliver on their design.
Well, they did drop an Audi engine in one of their cars: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamborghini_Urus#Powertrain
In industries where maintenance still has to happen, you see these general specs still in use. ARINC is one set that I deal with every day - they publish tons - along with many various MIL-STD things.
As the article points out, sometimes the spare parts are extremely simple things like bolts and screws, which should really be standardized across all industries.
Things like motors/switches and other simple electric components can also be (and should be) mostly standardized. It's only once you get to circuits and complex electronic boards that you will run into issues, because they can be custom.
Most consumer products aren't complicated, and if they are, they are only complicated because the company is trying to create huge markups and prevent people from repairing items.
i just have no idea how you begin to create a global system of "generic parts" beyond screws and bolts in a world of globalized supply chains, with specialized production in every country.
but i also have no experience in manufacturing or repair. i'd love to hear if there are any successful case studies on the subject