Having been on the other side of these brain problems, I understand your skepticism. I have many apparently-normal friends that, once a month or so, disappear off the face of the planet and eventually they come back and they're like "I thought everyone hated me so I stopped going to work and talking to my friends". My honest thought is "WTF" but I offer them reassurances that that's not true at all and everyone likes them. Then they're OK for another month. Meanwhile behind the scenes, they're seeing a psychiatrist and a therapist every couple weeks, and the fact that they're around at all, ever, is because of this work with their doctors. You have to accept that people's brains are wired differently, often in harmful ways, and that there are treatment options available. It's totally alien to me to be too unhappy to get out of bed. But it does happen to people, the data says it. So I believe the data and try to be supportive.
I really think not sticking to a diet is the same sort of problem.