News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Problem Is Not Plagiarism, but Cargo Cult Science by PaulHoule on Thursday January 18, 2024 @05:38PM (#39048883)
These guys have a systematic methodology for doing meta-analysis in health

https://www.cochrane.org/

The process starts with doing a literature search and then culling low-quality results which is almost always most of them because most studies in health have too small of a sample size, lack controls, and have other basic flaws. I saw one the other day where they found 80 studies but could only include two in the analysis.

Physics has its own hall of shame. It's quite likely that a large fraction of high energy physics is "not even wrong" in that there's not any evidence that the universe has 10 dimensions or that supersymmetry exist. In my field we used to make a plot on log-log paper, draw a line on it and say we'd discovered a power law so we published a lot of junk papers like this one

https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9512055

Mark Newman was at our institute at the time and after he finally got tenure a decade later he wrote a paper that put the smack down on it but it was in a statistics journal so for all I know people are still doing it wrong.

One of the reasons why I never really found my voice as a scientist was that I never found reconciliation between the ideal of scientific truth and the reality that there is a lot of bullshit (e.g. if you don't publish some bullshit you'll perish)

There are no comments on this comment yet.