Re:The Problem Is Not Plagiarism, but Cargo Cult Science
by sega_sai on Thursday January 18, 2024 @05:29PM
(#39048786)
From Andrew Gelman: "Any sufficiently crappy research is indistinguishable from fraud" https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2016/06/20/clarkes-la...
As for Neri Oxman, the kind of word salad she spit out is definitely reminiscent of cargo cult behavior, but the motivation is different: if you're in a cult, you're a believer, whereas it's not clear to me that Oxman believes her own nonsense, and in any event she seems to tend to borrow stuff from other fields and does not presume to contribute to those fields. Consequently, her research doesn't really qualify as the kind of mimicking without understanding that Feynmen was talking about.
So I guess I must ask: is Sven Schnieders (the author) cargo culting about cargo cult science?