News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Problem Is Not Plagiarism, but Cargo Cult Science by bertil on Thursday January 18, 2024 @04:26PM (#39047987)
I didn’t look too deeply into the scandal about plagiarism (because seeing people I admire fight like kids makes me sad), but I saw one glimpse: one accusation was comparing the Literature section of two papers by a PI and their Ph.D. student, and finding the two first paragraphs matched.

Dude, that’s the “You must read this before taking the class” segment of the paper. It’s a human-legible context for the Reference list (and occasionally, the opportunity for some minor pettiness against the competing lab). No one reads it (except Master’s students trying to catch up), and of course, it’s copy-pasted between two papers on the same topic.

After that, I kind of skipped the topic.

Re:The Problem Is Not Plagiarism, but Cargo Cult Science by stdbrouw on Thursday January 18, 2024 @04:43PM (#39048224)
Actually, no, people don't generally copy-paste parts of each others' literature review sections.
Re:The Problem Is Not Plagiarism, but Cargo Cult Science by bertil on Thursday January 18, 2024 @04:46PM (#39048257)
I’m convinced it’s not done in many areas of science. I have seen it done extensively in others.

The point is: I’m not sure doing it should be qualified as plagiarism.