Re:No One's Name Was Changed at Ellis Island
by snakeyjake on Thursday January 18, 2024 @03:32PM
(#39047246)
There were likely thousands of misakes.
None by Ellis Island personnel.
I don't know what your understanding of what happened there is, but it seems wrong.
Ellis Island personnel did not ask for and then reissue names to people. They checked pre-existing lists, and then those lists were filed away never to be looked again, except for by historians debunking the Ellis Island name change myth.
Even if a clerk said "your name's Joe Sch'mozle now" it didn't change anything. Ellis Island personnel didn't issue a single scrap of paper to the immigrants and did not write down the name of anyone passing through.
All they did was look at a list of names the ships arriving into port had, and make sure nobody not on the list came through (sans bribe).
None by Ellis Island personnel.
I don't know what your understanding of what happened there is, but it seems wrong.
Ellis Island personnel did not ask for and then reissue names to people. They checked pre-existing lists, and then those lists were filed away never to be looked again, except for by historians debunking the Ellis Island name change myth.
Even if a clerk said "your name's Joe Sch'mozle now" it didn't change anything. Ellis Island personnel didn't issue a single scrap of paper to the immigrants and did not write down the name of anyone passing through.
All they did was look at a list of names the ships arriving into port had, and make sure nobody not on the list came through (sans bribe).