News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Like Obsidian by geoelectric on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:15AM (#39038173)
Yeah, I wasn’t super-thrilled with their response. OTOH, I eventually came back to using it, my (arguably justified) snit in that thread notwithstanding.

I kept trialing alternatives like VimWiki, Joplin and Logseq, but everything else is even quirkier. Org.mode is about the only thing that seemed really competitive, but since I’m not an emacs person there’s a big ramp there for me. Plus, as with most of the alternatives, that loses Markdown compatibility entirely.

For now, Obsidian + Obsidian Tasks just does way too good a job for my work journaling for me to completely ignore. Plugins do work around most of the more questionable behavior, though it does sometimes make for an inconsistent experience.

Re learn new hotkeys, that’s actually not been a huge issue. Most of them simply aren’t mapped by default, which is its own pain. I did a lot of bouncing between VSCode hotkey lists and the Obsidian hotkeys UI to align shortcuts. At least they do enable you to remap most every UI action. I haven’t used the built-in vim bindings, but supposedly they also work fairly well, fwiw.

I would love to see a direct competitor that was fully open source, though. That team spends a lot of time working on things I don’t need like Canvas, when there’s still a fair bit of UI jank left to polish in the main experience.

There are no comments on this comment yet.