Re:Many AI safety orgs have tried to criminalize currently-e...
by tsimionescu on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:14AM
(#39025304)
I think we might actually be overall in agreement, just using different language. I believed that by legalization you meant something similar to how weed was legalized in various places - fully legal with minimal restrictions akin to alcohol or tobacco.
If you're for making it fully legal but heavily regulated, somewhat akin to a prescription drug, then I more or less agree.
Re:Many AI safety orgs have tried to criminalize currently-e...
by ben_w on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:29PM
(#39030717)
I think heroin is available on prescription in the UK?
https://www.jrf.org.uk/prescribing-heroin-what-is-the-eviden....
My elevator-pitch-summary understanding of UK drugs laws is that almost anything can be prescribed by a doctor, but almost everything is illegal unless a doctor does so, and there's 3 levels of severity if you have or supply something without that authorisation.
Certainly not advocating doing anything the way the US does it, in almost any respect. But the pharma thing is fundamentally a different issue. The reason people so easily become addicted to painkillers is because they're initially given for pain by someone they trust, while unbeknownst to them they've actually been given too much, for too long. In other words this is an issue of doctors abusing their authority.
Why don't I think it would get worse? Because of cultural norms. Legalising heroin won't make it cool and socially acceptable to use. People don't actually derive their social values solely from what happens to be legal.
Let me ask you a question. Why isn't everyone an alcoholic or a smoker? Why do they become rarer(in the west) despite those drugs being legal?
(Hint: the reason is cultural).