News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by rayiner on Sunday January 14, 2024 @06:44PM (#38995665)
> Amanda’s daughter Marie attended private school, speaks Mandarin, had an unweighted GPA of 4.1, and earned a 1560 on the SAT… Marie currently attends a university that did not make the U.S. News & World Report list of top-50 public schools

How is it possible not to get into a state flagship with a 1500+ SAT? If I was white or Asian with college aged kids I’d move to Texas or Georgia.

Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by amluto on Sunday January 14, 2024 @08:19PM (#38996297)
There are 50 states, and a lot of private universities are on the top 50 list, and several states have more than one state university on the list (hi, California), so most states have zero. University of Connecticut seems to be #58.

Not that the US News ranking is particularly meaningful.

Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Sunday January 14, 2024 @07:37PM (#38996017)
Texas and Georgia are states huge numbers of people would never consider moving too because of their horrific politics - a rather direct reflection of the average.
Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by pyuser583 on Sunday January 14, 2024 @07:49PM (#38996076)
Texas and Georgia both have massive immigration from other states.

People vote with their feet.

Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by dctoedt on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @02:22PM (#39017720)
> Texas and Georgia both have massive immigration from other states. People vote with their feet.

The technical term for this is "race to the bottom," abetted by short-term thinking on the part of "customers." It's similar to how people complain bitterly about the quality of air travel, but then go for the lowest-possible air fare.

(OK, the actual technical term is "revealed preference vs. expressed [or stated] preference.")

Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by pyuser583 on Thursday January 18, 2024 @04:31PM (#39048053)
People leaving the Bay Area for Austin and Georgia is hardly a race to the bottom.

The Bay Area has insane housing costs because of toxic zoning regulations.

Austin is a firmly blue city with extensive public services.

The parts Georgia Bay Area folks are moving to are similar politically and socially.

A better description is “people who value a well run city leave their poorly run city and move to a well run city.”

Corporations doing business in the country with the least environmental regulation is a race to the bottom.

Big corporations opening campuses in lightly populated suburbs is a race to the bottom.

Ships flying flages of convenience in third world countries is a race to the bottom.

People leaving a poorly run place to a well run place is not a race to the bottom.

When a person moves from the Dominican Republic to New York, that’s not a race to the bottom.

Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by FooBarBizBazz on Sunday January 14, 2024 @08:00PM (#38996163)
Yes, there are a handful of policy areas where the politics really do matter -- if you need it, did the state sign up for Medicaid expansion? If abortion may sadly be necessary, is it legal there? -- but I think in most areas, day to day life is no more oppressive in those states, and frequently the demographics are no less diverse.

In fact, we need to keep in mind the magnitude of coercion, or even oppression, that arises simply from economic forces. If the states with the "good politics" can't supply housing at a reasonable price, and if their affordable universities won't let your kids in, then what good are they? A red state with "bad politics" may be sufficiently cheap that the freedom it offers from wage-slavery may outweigh whatever oppressive laws are on the books there. The same goes for other countries. Suppose a country nominally has an authoritarian ruler -- it is not a democracy -- but he leaves ordinary apolitical people alone, and prices are reasonable. Maybe that's still a perfectly nice place to live? Maybe it's better than struggling to pay rent in the "good place"?

As for Texas and Georgia, local politics also matter. Some of the cities are blue islands. So you can't judge a county based only on what state it's in.

But if people are so blinkered that it's literally worth their entire life's wages just to own a house in the "good place", then I guess that's their problem.

That's my issue. The sheer amounts of money we're talking about are staggering. And you have to survive within an abusive corporate structure to get the money. Why tolerate that?

Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by telotortium on Monday January 15, 2024 @06:39PM (#39007557)
Honestly, for abortion, if it's that important to you and you have the capacity to get a professional job there, you have the capacity to book a flight to California etc. to get an abortion, or even just get abortion pills mailed to you from a Silk Road-like site.

On the plus side, for the rest of your life, including especially if you actually want to raise a child, red states are much better in most ways unless you have a very high salary in a coastal blue state (or your income is low enough to get benefits from the blue states, but your income won't be low enough if you're a professional).

Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by supertimor on Monday January 15, 2024 @10:00PM (#39008899)
>”On the plus side, for the rest of your life, including especially if you actually want to raise a child, red states are much better in most ways…”

Well unless your a woman with pregnancy complications that are life threatening. Then your out of luck. Hopefully you can catch a flight to California in time before you go into septic shock.

Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by jsyang00 on Sunday January 14, 2024 @07:28PM (#38995965)
possibly they did not apply
Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by huehehue on Sunday January 14, 2024 @08:30PM (#38996356)
Probably because these colleges have 5,000 Maries to choose from. The article says Marie is perfect on paper and "checks all the boxes", but that's honestly not very inspiring and I'd guess that applicants/parents are optimizing for the wrong things.

> “She’s happy but often says, ‘Mom, I just wish I hadn’t studied. I would have gotten into the exact same schools.’” And Marie is probably right. Admissions scarcity is concentrated at the top of the rankings list; there are hundreds of four-year colleges that readily admit B and C students.

My experience is that they actually would have gotten into more / better schools

Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by pknomad on Sunday January 14, 2024 @11:33PM (#38997492)
Perhaps she's from California?

UC Berkeley, UCLA, USC, UC Davis UC Irvine have insane freshmen profile and it's possible that she went to school that might not be nationally ranked but is a good school on its own right (i.e. Cal Poly).

Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by tptacek on Monday January 15, 2024 @12:05AM (#38997630)
In which states can't you? California? You're a mortal lock for Illinois with those stats.
Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by rayiner on Monday January 15, 2024 @12:34AM (#38997736)
I don’t know, I’m asking. Have state flagships become that competitive? I got into UIUC, Perdue, and GT (all top 50) with a similar SAT and much worse GPA. But that was 22 years ago. I think GT had a 60% acceptance rate my year. But University of Maryland, which wasn’t even on my radar back then, somehow has an SAT median of 1450 now. That used to near-Ivy range back when I was applying.
Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by tptacek on Monday January 15, 2024 @12:44AM (#38997768)
Madison, Illinois, and Michigan are competitive, but I don't think any of them are competitive to the point where top tier grades and test scores aren't getting you in anymore.
Re:Kids of parents making $158.2-222.4k/yr have worst odds o... by pcwalton on Monday January 15, 2024 @12:34PM (#39003578)
Bad idea re. Texas. UT Austin is extremely difficult to get into nowadays.