News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Java String Interpolation final in Java 23 by coldtea on Saturday January 13, 2024 @10:05AM (#38980578)
>How is it better?

Much more older and common use and association (even their own "Java EE Expression Language" uses it), and not confused with escaping a character (like \n, \t) etc.

Pricinple of least surprise, avoiding NIH, and stuff.

Re:Java String Interpolation final in Java 23 by pron on Sunday January 14, 2024 @08:26AM (#38990175)
> Much more older and common use and association (even their own "Java EE Expression Language" uses it)

That was one of the main reasons not to use it; even in JS templating libraries use different syntax from that of the language's $ (see my other comment).

> and not confused with escaping a character (like \n, \t) etc

That would not be a confusion at all but the very point: \{ is just like \n or \t, i.e. gets a special interpretation rather than a literal one.

> Pricinple of least surprise

\ in Java is standard for that purpose (special interpretation in a literal); it is $ that is foreign.

> avoiding NIH

That is not so much of a principle, although it could be if the language was rejecting some otherwise universal choice, only that's not the case here at all. Of the other popular language with either a similar feature to Java's string templates or with string interpolation -- JS, Python, PHP, C#, and Ruby -- only JS and PHP use $ (and only PHP uses $ with the "shell" shortcut of $x). Or, if you only want to look at the "big three" -- JS, Python, and Java -- each has a different syntax from the other two, and only one uses $. Even if you look at all programming languages in the world, only a minority of programmers using a language with string templates and/or string interpolation use one where $ is used for the value syntax. Not only is it not a near universal choice, it's a minority choice.