Re:Unity's Open-Source Double Standard: The Ban of VLC
by tzs on Saturday January 13, 2024 @02:10AM
(#38977933)
I just ran this shell script on my Mac:
#!/bin/sh
say Alexa what time is it
and my Amazon Echo told me the time. Is that shell script a derivative work of Amazon's Alexa code? It is very clearly designed to depend on Alexa.
Re:Unity's Open-Source Double Standard: The Ban of VLC
by simiones on Monday January 15, 2024 @03:31AM
(#38998578)
I don't know, no one really does as this has never been tested in courts as far as I know. I believe the FSF would say that it's not a derivative work, as it doesn't interact with the Alexa code through complex data types. However, this is their own legal theory, not directly a part of any law or jurisprudence (as far as I know - if there is some case law on this topic, I would be very curious to read it).
I think this is very much debatable, and I believe the FSF at least takes the position that greet.c is a derived work of Y since it is designed to depend on Y. Even more, their position is that a program like this:
Is quite possibly a derived work of GCC, since it depends critically on communicating with GCC using a very complex and specific data interchange format (the GCC-specific C source code). Note that this is not including any portion of GCC itself, even after compilation.Now, this type of thing has never been tested in a court of law as far as I know, so it's difficult to say whose interpretation of copyright and its implications is actually correct. But this is similar to the idea that if you were to write an original novel that uses characters or very recognizable aspects of, say, The Lord of the Rings, you'd be creating a derived work (and thus permission from the Tolkien estate), even if you didn't include any part of the original longer than "Galadriel".