Re:Austerity Is an Antidemocratic Strategy to Boost Capital
by pi-e-sigma on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:27PM
(#38942631)
Well, now we have empirical experience that after abolishing gold standard we still have economic crashes so getting rid of it didn't help us. So you can't really claim that gold standard was actually worse at preventing crashes. But we also have undesired things that weren't possible before such as FED's ability to print unlimited amount of money. That was my initial point and I stand by it. The gold standard wasn't great but at least it kept the monetary policy anchored to the reality.
Re:Austerity Is an Antidemocratic Strategy to Boost Capital
by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:43PM
(#38943648)
If you have empirical evidence that, after abolishing the gold standard, economic crashes were still as frequent and as severe as they were under the gold standard, I'd love to see it. Until I do, I'm skeptical that any such evidence exists, because I'm pretty sure that they have not been as frequent or as severe.
> The gold standard wasn't great but at least it kept the monetary policy anchored to the reality.
I will agree with you that the Fed policy is less constrained by reality than it would be under the gold standard. I think the new actually works better, but I admit that the lack of constraint is a serious concern.
Re:Austerity Is an Antidemocratic Strategy to Boost Capital
by pi-e-sigma on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @05:22PM
(#38944234)
We don't really have empirical evidence that abandoning the gold standard reduced frequency and severity of crashes, either. Gold standard (or silver) has been the norm for centuries and we are only 50 years in without it in the US. So it's all a matter of opinion.
Re:Austerity Is an Antidemocratic Strategy to Boost Capital
by AnimalMuppet on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:22AM
(#38951863)
It's not only a matter of opinion. 50 years of data is not nothing.
> Gold standard wasn't great but in hindsight it actually worked better what we have now.
You didn't specify what it worked better at, just asserted that overall it worked better.
I replied that it was specifically worse at preventing crashes (implying that it therefore was reasonable to question whether it was overall better).
You reply that the crashes were not specifically caused by the gold standard. Perhaps not, but they were part of the way things worked under the gold standard. You can't argue that things as a whole worked better, and then argue that all the parts that didn't work better weren't part of what you were talking about.
Is there any particular reason to blame the crashes on the gold standard? Well, the gold standard prevented someone like the Fed from doing what the Fed does these days to keep them from being so severe. So, maybe the gold standard wasn't the cause, but it was part of the problem.