News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Python, Why Are You So Ugly? by cageface on Thursday April 26, 2012 @10:43AM (#3894148)
Good design is a signal. If the people behind a product took the time to make something look good it's likely that they sweated the other details too.

Especially when two products are close to functionally interchangeable, like Ruby and Python, design can be decisive. Engineers chronically underestimate the importance of design and marketing.

Re:Dear Python, Why Are You So Ugly? by viraptor on Thursday April 26, 2012 @11:01AM (#3894222)
Ruby and Python are. But look at the origin of popularity. Python was popular in academia / system scripts for a long time. Ruby's popularity comes in a large part from Rails.

Now guess which community has better graphical design skills? Or from the other end - all other things being equal (and of course they aren't in reality, there are many small differences), I'd rather use a language designed by someone who specialises in designing programming languages rather than one creating websites.

Re:Dear Python, Why Are You So Ugly? by cageface on Thursday April 26, 2012 @11:09AM (#3894267)
I'd rather use a language designed by someone who specialises in designing programming languages rather than one creating websites.

Are you referring to PHP or something? Certainly Matz is every bit the language designer Guido is. Like it or not, Python and Ruby are competing in a lot of very similar niches. Fluffing the design of your webpages is like stopping at the 24th mile of a marathon.

Re:Dear Python, Why Are You So Ugly? by stonemetal on Thursday April 26, 2012 @11:24AM (#3894336)
From Matz's wiki entry: He graduated with an information science degree from University of Tsukuba, where he was a member of Ikuo Nakata's research lab on programming languages and compilers.

Doesn't sound like someone who specializes in creating websites to me.

Re:Dear Python, Why Are You So Ugly? by viraptor on Thursday April 26, 2012 @11:36AM (#3894398)
No, I wasn't trying to point out anything about Ruby's creators. The preference bit was a PS I could actually skip... but it's there.

I do however think that high popularity in one specific circle (rails developers) results in pretty pages about the language itself. The split was actually very clear not that long ago even in ruby itself. A couple of months ago docs for ruby core were on a really ugly and not very usable page with 3 small scrolling boxes on the top and documentation view below. It's gone now fortunately. (old version of rdoc generator theme - still visible on http://stdlib.rubyonrails.org/libdoc/rdoc/rdoc/index.html)

Re:Dear Python, Why Are You So Ugly? by Trufa on Thursday April 26, 2012 @10:51AM (#3894179)
This is true, I'm really more likely to put my credit card in a website that looks awesome than in one that doesn't. It immediately gives you some sense of trust.

Disclaimer: you should't base your credit card use only on design!

Re:Dear Python, Why Are You So Ugly? by givanfp on Thursday April 26, 2012 @11:16AM (#3894300)
Have you ever seen MSDN or JDK docs?
Re:Dear Python, Why Are You So Ugly? by yazmeya on Thursday April 26, 2012 @11:42AM (#3894432)
yes. horrible from any perspective.
Re:Dear Python, Why Are You So Ugly? by GlennS on Thursday April 26, 2012 @11:38AM (#3894407)
Consider that signals mean different things to different people.

These Python sites are targeted at Python programmers. What do Python programmers want? They want clean, neat and obvious. Above all they cannot abide unnecessary clutter.

The Ruby screenshots listed have the following 'visual impact' features. They may make them more attractive, but don't help with usability and potentially get take up space that could be used for information:

  Elements introduced purely for decoration.
  Oversized logos
  Pictures of people
  Designer fonts
By contrast, the Python pages are all information dense and organised with hierarchies of headers.

This is a pretty rough analysis, but perhaps it explains the difference in approach?

Re:Dear Python, Why Are You So Ugly? by pwf on Thursday April 26, 2012 @11:51AM (#3894487)
It's definitely a signal, though I don't take to mean quite what you do...

It's only 'likely that they sweated the other details' if you assume infinite manpower and resources. In reality, all of the very finite resources that went into picking the right shade of beige for the background could have instead gone into improving the actual tools.

I don't think it's possible for an engineer to underestimate the importance of design and marketing for an engineering tool.

Have you seen nginx.org?

Re:Dear Python, Why Are You So Ugly? by cnlwsu on Thursday April 26, 2012 @11:22AM (#3894329)
Some overestimate the importance of design, take a look at some ugly sites that are successful http://www.ebay.com/ or http://www.craigslist.org
Re:Dear Python, Why Are You So Ugly? by cageface on Thursday April 26, 2012 @11:26AM (#3894341)
You can succeed without good design if you have no real competition. Both those sites also established themselves when design standards on the web were very primitive. Good luck finding the same success with that approach now.