News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by ezyang on Thursday April 26, 2012 @01:20AM (#3892548)
Suppose you have a system, but for legal liability reasons you cannot have this system be open to users (say it's a medical system, and having untrained people fuck around with it messes with certification.) However, you make it reasonably easy for users to override any interlocks (i.e. put in no protection).

A user finds out about the override, hacks their device, misprograms it, and dies.

Is the company that manufactured this device legally liable for this death? If they knew that it was easy to override the safety interlocks, are they then liable? How about if there was demonstrable evidence that the knew about the specific override? What if they, in an informal capacity, spread information about how to do the override?

Here is a parallel situation: same company makes a device, and has locked it down so hard that it's not possible to actually get anything done with it. Nurses and other trained practitioners know that "the usual way of business" is to override some of the safeguards, because, of course, that's the only one anyone ever gets any work done. However, the company disclaims all legal liability in the case that someone does such a modification. Are they allowed to disclaim that?

It's complicated.

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by shabble on Thursday April 26, 2012 @02:59AM (#3892805)
This has happened, to some extent:

At the Instituto Oncologico Nacional in Panama, some doctors discovered that they could fudge things to circumvent some limitations in the software that calculated shielding block geometry for radiotherapy patients.

In essence, the system could only handle 4 blocks, but it was possible (and sometimes correct) to add more than one block as a single shape. If this happened in the wrong order, however, it would screw up.

The staff in charge were brought up on civil (and possibly criminal) negligence charges, from what I recall.

Edit: Yep, according to http://www.scielosp.org/scielo.php?pid=S1020-498920060008000...

[search for "Legal actions" heading]

"On 18 November 2004 it was announced that one of the physicists was acquitted, but the other two were found guilty, sentenced to four years in prison, and barred from practicing their profession for seven years (45). They have initiated an appeal process, but they are very worried, given the precedent established by the Costa Rica case.

The [...] Costa Rican physicist [...] was accused of negligence in 30 homicides and 59 radiation injuries. He was also accused of falsifying documents and of using false documents. On 30 July 2001 he was absolved of the latter two charges, but he was found guilty of 14 homicides and 50 radiation injuries. He was sentenced to six years in prison and barred from practicing his profession for five years."

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instituto_Oncologico_Nacional#...

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by ars on Thursday April 26, 2012 @03:13AM (#3892844)
It's quite different to do this for yourself vs for other people.
Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by sirrocco on Thursday April 26, 2012 @01:37AM (#3892590)
No it's not. At the doctor's office you should be told: "Don't fuck around with the machine. If you need to change the settings, come to me and I'll change it. You also have this hand-book of how to override, but if you do you might die."

It's simple. You were warned.

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by wickedchicken on Thursday April 26, 2012 @01:41AM (#3892602)
> It's simple. You were warned.

laws don't work like that

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by chao- on Thursday April 26, 2012 @01:56AM (#3892653)
Not to nitpick, because I agree, but I think it's a more accurate to say "litigation doesn't work like that" or "lawyers don't work like that". I was under the impression that it's less a specific law which spells out the liability, but rather a patchwork of regulation and court cases that leave a company with so much uncertainty that the only intelligent choice is to cover your ass any-which-way that you can.

My impression (and it is merely that) comes from today's earlier discussion on liability, regulations and compliance: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3889512

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by micks56 on Thursday April 26, 2012 @02:17AM (#3892709)
Not totally accurate. There isn't much uncertainty in the law, but rather whether you broke it. Plaintiff has the burden of proof. And while there may not be a specific statute spelling out liability, case law has equal wait in the US.

Here is an example. This is a common 3 part test used to decide whether a manufacturer is liable for failure to warn:

1. Manufacturer had actual knowledge of the alleged danger

2. Manufacturer had no reason to know that consumers would know of this danger.

3. Manufacturer failed to exercise reasonable care to inform customers of the danger.

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by chao- on Thursday April 26, 2012 @02:30AM (#3892747)
...case law has equal weight in the US.

That is what I meant to express, and I stand corrected on the details.

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by Karunamon on Thursday April 26, 2012 @02:00AM (#3892659)
I've been using this quote over and over the past month and this seems a good occasion as any:

Lawyers fucking ruin everything.

That really sums up pretty much everything wrong with this whole system.

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by JamesLeonis on Thursday April 26, 2012 @03:00AM (#3892810)
While I don't necessarily disagree, that's like saying hackers ruin everything. What do lawyers (hackers) do but try to find weaknesses in the current law (program) and exploit them? We haven't figured out how to make perfectly secure systems that are still usable, so why do we expect our laws to be any more robust?
Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by micks56 on Thursday April 26, 2012 @02:19AM (#3892713)
I'm not defending the legal field in its entirety, but your opinion would change if you or your loved one were harmed or killed.
Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by Karunamon on Thursday April 26, 2012 @12:26PM (#3894665)
My loved ones are smart enough to not dick around with life sustaining hardware and software.

On a less snarky note, it's absurd that I can't do what I want with something I bought and paid for, whether that be a game console or a breathing mask. It's not the law's job to protect me from myself.

And I say lawyers ruin everything because the legal profession has a vested interest in keeping the lay person from being able to understand and use the law effectively. including such idiocy as the OP's scenario.

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by Retric on Thursday April 26, 2012 @01:33PM (#3895088)
Having actually been in that situation; I respectfully disagree.
Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by Cushman on Thursday April 26, 2012 @04:04PM (#3895849)
> And I say lawyers ruin everything because the legal profession has a vested interest in keeping the lay person from being able to understand and use the law effectively.

This may be true, but it is not the reason law is hard for the lay person to understand.

Western legal theory has taken "justice" to mean that, given the same facts, and irrespective of the personal opinions of the judge or jury, the court should reach the same decision. Just think about that for a second-- it's not an easy problem. In fact it's a fabulously difficult problem, even before you add the condition that the system should remain fair over time in excess of a human lifespan.

The (clearly sub-optimal) solution we've arrived at over the past few thousand years is basically to implement an enormous natural-language virtual machine in which individual agents (lawyers) execute programs (laws) using a very precisely-defined instruction set (legal jargon) which is very similar in structure to English. The reason the laws cannot be written in English is that English has natural ambiguities; this is fine for conversation, but is absolutely unacceptable when human freedom or livelihood is on the line.

The obvious downside is that it means that average citizens can actually not learn the law simply by reading the law. To mitigate that, we've constructed an execution context in which a separate lawyer represents each interested party, with a judge acting as a neutral third party present to represent the interests of the law. The jury is asked only to establish the facts; understanding of the law is not required. It's really all pretty clever.

Obviously it's not perfect. But, before you criticize the system wholesale, remember that law didn't always work this way. Time was you would just take your grievance before the king, and depending on if he was feeling merciful or surly or liked your family, you would either get what you wanted or not. If you were lucky, there would be rhyme or reason to the king's judgments, and you might be able to predict what he'd say. If not, well... sucks to be you.

The complexity of the law, the cost of employing full-time legal scholars for every interaction, and the occasional abuses of the system-- these are the price we pay for fairness.

I'm not saying I think lawyers are awesome, but a world without them would be a hell of a lot worse than most people think.

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by Retric on Thursday April 26, 2012 @09:25PM (#3897017)
That's only true on the surface. In the US lawyers execute not just statue (laws written by the legislator and signed into law by the executive that have yet to be over turned) but case law. Which acts as a single vary large multidimentional training set that's clear at the extremes but vary vague in the middle. The reason it's vague is people pretend there is far more stability in the system than actually exists so there is case law supporting any vaguely reasonable line of argument. Thus, lawyers are there not to help interpret the law, but create the most reasonable argument supporting their clients goals and providing their clients feedback to how well that argument might stand up in court. Under this interpretation you can clearly see how a talented team of lawyers can help bend the law to their client's point of view and 'distort' the impartiality of the system.
Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by Cushman on Thursday April 26, 2012 @10:32PM (#3897216)
Case law is still about fairness, though. The ideal is that the same facts should be decided the same way. Of course, since no case ever has exactly the same circumstances as a previous one, there's always some wiggle room to argue that this one is more like that one or the other one and so should be decided in that particular way. The adversarial system is a way to try to balance that; you make your best argument, I make my best argument, and somebody disinterested decides which one they buy.

Saying "you can use case law to support any argument" is hyperbole; you can use any case which was been decided the way you'd like in the past, and the older the statute the more cases have been decided and the more wiggle room you have. But it's not a binary thing; the strength of your argument is affected by how similar the circumstances are, how much body of precedent there is for and against, how close the jurisdiction was, the reasoning given for the previous decision, and many other factors.

Of course this is really hard to keep track of if you're not a full-time legal scholar in that particular area of law, and it makes the whole thing seem even more impenetrable to the rest of us. But again, it's all in the spirit of fairness. It's not perfect, but consider the alternative: a justice system where previous decisions didn't matter -- where the law was just "the law", decided fresh by whatever judge you happen to stand before -- would be far more capricious.

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by sirrocco on Thursday April 26, 2012 @02:04AM (#3892668)
Yeap, I'll have to agree with Karunamon bellow :

"Lawyers fucking ruin everything."

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by chao- on Thursday April 26, 2012 @02:27AM (#3892737)
Except when they save you money? As in the famous "Fuck you. Pay me." video: http://vimeo.com/22053820

I think it's more nuanced than simply "Lawyers are bad!" The cost of litigation, even when you are likely to win, is so high that it encourages whatever behaviors best avoid litigation, rather than whatever behavior fulfills the original goals of the company/sector/system. Companies and even entire sectors, once well-established, would rather optimize for continual, guaranteed success within a subpar ecosystem than risk losing big just to allow an environment of marginally more satisfied "informed consumers", or what-have-you.

Edit: I am rambling about "the system" and such, without offering any solutions, partly because I'm at a loss for one. The best I can muster would be for legal fees and penalties to be in a range that does not warrant selecting such behavior. But that topic is a deep rabbit hole unto itself.

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by micks56 on Thursday April 26, 2012 @02:21AM (#3892719)
Failure to warn is only one component of liability. There is design defect, manufacturing defect, negligence, and so on.

"It's complicated" is very accurate.

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by chao- on Thursday April 26, 2012 @02:42AM (#3892773)
Though I don't presume to have read his mind, I feel like sirrocco is falling prey to a line of thought that I often do with regards to law. As a programmer, I often want to build some sort of deterministic decision tree regarding matters. The instinct of "Once I have all possible behaviors and paths modeled, an optimal solution will present itself!" is a strong one.

And then my friends in law school remind me, sometimes loudly, how the facts or circumstances can vary greatly, and how nothing in life is quite that simple. Alas.

Re:If We Told You That, We Would Have to Shoot You by overgard on Thursday April 26, 2012 @02:32AM (#3892750)
It may be complicated, but that doesn't make it any less outrageous. And it seems like "complicated" problems tend to go away rather quickly when enough people become sufficiently outraged.

Or more to the point: we shouldn't be making excuses for people blatantly fucking us over. Let them make their own excuses. Even better, let them get out of the way.