I think that if somebody is sitting there with a bunch of stuff they are eager to start selling, they are not going to mind pulling out a credit card and spending $20-$30 to get started. That's why I think these guys should raise their prices to capture that impulse buy up-front. I think there is a lot of value in knowing the brand. If I know Shopify is a proven product, I'll probably pay a premium rather than try an unknown service.
Big Cartel is a fairly established player in the "run your own storefront" game. With their most basic plan you can edit your storefront CSS, they don't take a percentage of sales, and you can have 5 products for free.
---
That said, I see ShopLocket as competing more with Gumroad than with the "storefront management" companies. If I want to open a storefront then I will open an Etsy/Shopify/Big Cartel store but if I already have a website and I want to now offer a few items for sale then I would use ShopLocket.
I would be glad to pay the current ShopLocket fee after my first sale but would not be willing to pay an upfront setup charge. What if I'm not sure that anyone wants the item I am trying to sell? I'm not a retailer, I'm just a guy who wants to try selling something. ShopLocket would be driving away a large number of amateur sellers if they put up that barrier to entry. With no upfront fee there is the chance of catching the amateur seller who is testing the waters then ends up with a hit, with an upfront fee that person would go use Gumroad.
I could see this being a great way for college students to sell tshirts to parties or groups to sell event tshirts on Facebook. Why not have them pay a larger listing fee up-front? I don't think there is necessarily a correlation between number of items and willingness to pay (especially if you are comparing to Shopify's $29/month plan which is aimed at small stores anyway).
Anyhow, this is a really interesting idea.