News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by skybrian on Monday January 08, 2024 @08:58PM (#38921251)
They studied whether the average American can use Google to fact-check news articles and the answer seems to be no. And in particular, some people seem to be really bad at using a search engine:

> So what do the low-google-fu people do to generate bad results? Often, they just literally plug the questionable article headline or URL into Google. If your search terms are “SHOCK REVELATION: SHILLARY CAUGHT DRINKING BABIES’ BLOOD AT MARTHA’S VINEYARD ESTATE,” Google’s probably going to give you results that go along with its assumptions.

But it doesn’t mean you can’t learn how to fact-check news articles, or that it can’t be taught.

It might be interesting to repeat the study for other groups. College graduates? Graduate students?

Also, I wonder if it’s possible to build a better search engine with this task in mind?

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by hetman on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:28PM (#38921488)
It can be taught but most people have little motivation to learn. Genuine verification of claims is a lot of hard work so for most people the question becomes: Why bother learning how?

First, the warm and fuzzy feeling you get by confirming your chosen world view doesn't take very much work. Just a couple minutes on Google.

Second, for many, the mere suggestion that there is a need to learn a new skill connected with research will likely be interpreted as an attack on their intelligence.

So the real question we have to be asking is how we can motivate people to even want to uncover truth even when it leads to discomfort. The answer is obvious for those who have already arrived there but not for those who haven't.

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by irjustin on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:29PM (#38921495)
This has always been the push/pull between strict democracy, republic, and benevolent dictatorship.

In a strict democracy, there are too many "idiots" who don't actually understand what the issue is. In a dictatorship you can get a CRAZY amount of things done (see Singapore, China), but all it takes is one/few bad egg(s) and sends the whole country into the stone age (see Philippines).

A republic seems pretty okay in the long term for now mostly because if there's too much infighting the country becomes a gridlock (like now), but that seems more like a feature than a bug.

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by bnralt on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:50PM (#38921652)
The main problem is that everyone thinks that it's something we have to teach other people to do, but few see this as something that they themselves have to get better at. In fact, people become simply hostile to others for doing this if it's a piece of information they like.

I just saw a quote yesterday taken out of context on Reddit, and one of the most highly upvoted comments was someone mocking people who want context. If the quote makes a bad person bad, than someone even bothering to look at whether or not it accurately portrayed the situation is the enemy trying to defend the bad person.

Everyone should put more effort into fact checking things they want to be true than things they don't, because it's usually when we want something to be true that we drop our guards.

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by a_gnostic on Monday January 08, 2024 @10:59PM (#38922135)
I wish I could upvote this more.
Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by vladms on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @05:54AM (#38924634)
Maybe we could take a step back and don't think in black and white. I do not "want something to be true", I give it a probability to be true between 0 and 1.

But the thing is that moving from binary (true/false) to continuous (probability) requires mental effort which many people prefer not (or are not able) to do.

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by bb88 on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:14PM (#38921364)
The cynic in me suggests that one of the political parties in the US doesn't really want the population well educated.

I also feel "fact check via google" is also the wrong way to go about it, because google just spits out whatever the internet says.

The reality is that a certain skeptical mindset is required when consuming news reports. And when the skepticism goes away, you end up with a cult. And that's not something that every school district teaches.

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by hetman on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:31PM (#38921519)
The cynic in me suggests this is true of both major parties in US politics. The sets of things they want to you learn and don't want you to learn -- usually because it's just too hard to have a public conversation due to ideological conflict -- those sets of things just happen to be different in either case.
Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by sugarplant on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:25PM (#38921467)
> The cynic in me suggests that one of the political parties in the US doesn't really want the population well educated.

yes just the single party that is the opposite of mine of course ;)

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by bb88 on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:37PM (#38921572)
I think you can be skeptical of Democrats as well as Republicans.

Here's a for instance:

In ruby red Idaho, where I live, Mike Lindell said that votes were switched from Trump to Biden. [1] Trump won with 64 % of the vote in Idaho.

Get this:

"Butte County after the election reported a tally of 1,193 votes for Trump and 188 for Biden. Lindell contended Biden only received 130. But the hand count of ballots found 188 to be accurate."

So Mike Lindell thinks the democrats reached into Butte county in Idaho and twisted 50 votes towards Biden!

[1] https://apnews.com/article/donald-trump-joe-biden-election-r....

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by the_gastropod on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:29PM (#38921498)
Oh my! A both-sideser!

Yep. Both U.S. political parties are equally problematic! No distinctions to be drawn, whatsoever!

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by insickness on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:44PM (#38921615)
Nope. Just one side is problematic. The other has a monopoly on wisdom and justice. Go team!
Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by happymellon on Monday January 08, 2024 @11:54PM (#38922490)
Not American so I have absolutely no skin in the game, so it's funny that your argument appears to be about something the other didn't say.

Republicans, much like the Tories here, appear to want to cut taxes because everything they say is about reducing government interference.

Not always a bad thing, but cutting taxes inherently means some services will get caught in the trim.

When your Department of Education releases things like this, I can see why you would ignore the highly emotional charged language

https://www.ed.gov/news/press-releases/fact-sheet-house-repu...

However I never see proposals from Republicans to improve education, just either cuts or demands to ban books. Do you have examples where they have proposed improvements to education? Without that then I'm afraid Republicans really do always to appear to be anti-education.

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by peyton on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @02:08AM (#38923293)
I think your view is perhaps twenty years out of date. Here’s the GOP platform with some proposals to improve education and reform the tax code:

https://prod-static.gop.com/media/Resolution_Platform.pdf

I don’t think any party is for slashing tax revenue anymore. The GOP wants a supermajority for raising taxes.

Reading the DoE press release you linked, it sounds like the objection is to double-dipping.

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by supertimor on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @08:18PM (#38934878)
I’m not sure if you read their education proposals, but their platform basically boils down to spend less money on public education and instead support charter schools, private schools and home schooling, etc., teach the bible in class, get rid of national educational standards, support abstinence instead of sex Ed, get rid of student counselling for contraception/abortions, get rid of government funded student mental health support, reinterpret Title IX to apply only to women/girls, and privatize the federal student loan program.

None these proposals are very education-forward at all, and are mostly just hot button issues to rile up the base. Each of these policies just decreases educational support and funding. How will any of these policies have any beneficial effect on the quality of education American’s receive?

Don’t even get me started with their stated tax policy. The Republicans’ entire platform on tax reform is to repeal the Johnson amendment, a ban on non-profit political campaign activity that prohibits non-profits (which includes churches) from participating in, or intervening in any political campaign on behalf of any candidate for political office; and to make the tax code “so simple and easy to understand that the IRS becomes obsolete and can be abolished.”[0] This is a literal quote from the 2016 Republican Platform that you linked. Yeah, let’s just abolish the IRS. That’s a super realistic policy.

Their tax policy is just laughable.

[0] https://prod-static.gop.com/media/Resolution_Platform.pdf

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by happymellon on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:41AM (#38936641)
Cheers, I had a quick glance at it and didn't understand how it supported their position at all.

That was 2016, which was Trump who gave you folks tax cuts and attacks on education. Completely mad.

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by supertimor on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @08:21PM (#38946156)
Yep, I honestly don’t get how people can seriously read this platform and claim in good faith that these are valid policy positions. The “evidence” they linked to support their claim ended up instead just supporting your original point that they were trying to refute. Agreed. Just completely mad.
Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by bb88 on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:47PM (#38921629)
And the other believes in a violent overthrow of congress because they can't string words together in a coherent thought to convince the other side?

I thought one of the benefits to the US was a "marketplace of ideas".

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by mrangle on Monday January 08, 2024 @10:12PM (#38921805)
Who violently overthrew Congress? Gaslighting doesn't help your argument.

Is the "markeptplace of ideas" like when the Media and the DNC incited mass riots for eight full months before the 2019 election, mass-terrorizing American voters? To what end? To make sure there was a "fair trial" (note: this assured the opposite)? Or to make sure that the preferred candidate was elected? Again, by targeting American voters.

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by bb88 on Monday January 08, 2024 @10:23PM (#38921883)
Who's gaslighting who?

I recall a certain January 6 even to which the convicted criminals Elaine Stefanik refers to as "Hostages".

Who are you talking about?

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by a_gnostic on Monday January 08, 2024 @11:05PM (#38922160)
That was when they almost burned down the White House Jefferson Church. Was a dark day for our sacred Democracy.
Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by mrangle on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @06:00PM (#38933548)
When was Congress overthrown? Which Congresspeople were harmed? Which Grandmas with American flags, now with criminal records, meant to take over the US government?

Yes, there are a lot of people in prison. They have been subject to norm-breaking prosecution under the opposition party's adminstration. Whenever an opposition party decides to arrest and prosecute its competition, they try to deflect from the authoritarian fact and deride those people as crimimnals as much as possible. This is the playbook for every tin-pot dictator since Sumer.

And in this instance, the authoritarians in question rode into office on eight months of nation-shattering street terrorism that their party incited and protected. Of course, the dictators proclaim those riots as perfectly legitimate and that of their competition as criminal. See: Tin Pot Dictator.

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by mrangle on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:33PM (#38921538)
There are, in fact, at least two positions on most issues that the English speaking world cares about. But why move the goal post from voter education to a discussion on the subjective badness of the two main parties? That is, if your aim is to make a point under the discussion being had.
Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by sugarplant on Monday January 08, 2024 @10:16PM (#38921830)
problematic about what? the idea of an "educated" voter is very childish

a lot of political topics, particularly foreign policy and economics, are far too complicated for ordinary people to be informed about. if you ever have the time i would recommend reading the book "propaganda" by jacques ellul. or just skimming the chapter titled "the necessity for propaganda." it's pretty relevant to the thread as well

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by hetman on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:35PM (#38921550)
I don't think he ever said "equally".
Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by the_gastropod on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:20PM (#38921421)
Firstly, I think you're right—and their policies very much so reflect this.

Re: the "skeptical mindset"—I think critical thought is essential. But that's a lot more complex than merely having a "skeptical mindset", which is effectively what these "Do your own research" type of people tend to have. They're skeptical of the "mainstream elites", and that's about the end of the thought process. They're very likely to buy most narratives that counters mainstream consensus.

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by mrangle on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:27PM (#38921478)
"one of"
Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by the_gastropod on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:38PM (#38921580)
Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by mrangle on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:42PM (#38921605)
You prior wrote "well educated".
Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by vladms on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @06:03AM (#38924688)
I wonder if there is some connection between prevalence of actual cults (or any organization built on belief, like churches or totalitarian regimes) and opposition to teaching on how to be skeptical.
Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by caseysoftware on Monday January 08, 2024 @10:15PM (#38921821)
> It might be interesting to repeat the study for other groups. College graduates? Graduate students?

College graduates are no longer a rarified group with high IQs:

We conducted a meta-analysis of the mean IQ scores of college and university students samples tested with Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale between 1939 and 2022. Results. The results show that the average IQ of undergraduate students today is a mere 102 IQ points and declined by approximately 0.2 IQ points per year.

Ref: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1309...

As a whole, their primary differentiator appears to be the ability to get loans.

Individual programs (by university or degree) vary though so cohort analysis by one of those may be useful.

Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by g-b-r on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:37PM (#38921569)
A much better search engine for most people is simply one not personalized to their tastes
Re:Asking people to "do the research" on fake news makes it ... by jfengel on Monday January 08, 2024 @09:20PM (#38921423)
Building a better search engine would be easy. Just cutting out the most egregiously delusional sites would go a long way.

But nobody would use it. People who are intent on confirming their biases scream "censorship" if you tell them they can't use their favorite sources of misinformation. They will swear up and down that they are capable of telling truth from lies, and even if they can't the lies are their natural born right.